New dudes and dudettes: Most annoying things about LOTR. - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

ohtatyaro · 02-04-2005, 06:14 AM

Several things, but most of all, probably, hyenas. I mean, wargs are wolves, just fell and clever, but not hyenas.

Some other things too. Aragorn scared to fight. Or scared is a too strong a word. Hesitant. that's it.

Gollum setting up Sam, also. I mean, Frodo believing Sam was a traitor, not Gollum trying to set him up.

Denethor chewing cherries, while there is a battle outside. I loathe that scene. It makes Denethor horrible, and in the books I liked him and was sorry when he died.

Merry and Pippin taken on a trip accidentally, just becuase they happened to be stealing maggots carrots and stumbled upon Frodo. If I haven't read about how they were friends with Frodo in the book, I would be thinkig something like 'what did these two asked for trouble for?' Who asked them to come at all? And then, in elrond's place, they are all eager to come. Ah, another scene - when they run into the secret council.

But on the whole, I liked the movies

02-04-2005, 06:14 AM	#26
ohtatyaro Wight Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: here, there, everywhere... Posts: 121	'tis about the movies, right? Several things, but most of all, probably, hyenas. I mean, wargs are wolves, just fell and clever, but not hyenas. Some other things too. Aragorn scared to fight. Or scared is a too strong a word. Hesitant. that's it. Gollum setting up Sam, also. I mean, Frodo believing Sam was a traitor, not Gollum trying to set him up. Denethor chewing cherries, while there is a battle outside. I loathe that scene. It makes Denethor horrible, and in the books I liked him and was sorry when he died. Merry and Pippin taken on a trip accidentally, just becuase they happened to be stealing maggots carrots and stumbled upon Frodo. If I haven't read about how they were friends with Frodo in the book, I would be thinkig something like 'what did these two asked for trouble for?' Who asked them to come at all? And then, in elrond's place, they are all eager to come. Ah, another scene - when they run into the secret council. But on the whole, I liked the movies __________________ Reading this sig costs three Galleons, nine Sickles, and a Knut. Pay up!