Oaths in the Fellowship - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

alatar · 03-03-2005, 10:13 AM

From memory, when leaving Rivendell Gimli proposes that they all take an oath. Someone (Elrond?) says that this might not be a good idea as no one can foresee what will happen along the way. Gimli counters that an oath may 'buck up' one's resolve when things get tough. In the end I think that no one makes a formal declaration.

Again if I remember correctly Aragorn says the line regarding "if by my life or death I can save you" or something to Frodo, but this may have been in Bree.

The Boromir thing from Sam doesn't sound right.

Boromir88 · 03-03-2005, 06:03 PM

I would argue that the meaning behind Elrond's, "...you that travel with him no oath or bond holds you to go further then you will". That's only talking about the members to continue to travel with Frodo. There was no oath that the members of the fellowship had to continue to travel with Frodo. However, I would say there was an oath that as long as a member stayed in the Fellowship, he had to protect Frodo, and help him on his quest. Sam's line refers to Boromir breaking that oath, to protect Frodo. The scene in the movies with all the members stepping in to join Frodo, is surely an oath to help him.

Aragorn: If by my life or death I can protect you I will! You have my sword!
blah blah blah...everyone else comes in.

Elrond's little phrase only ment the members didn't have to continue to travel with Frodo, as the line says.

03-03-2005, 06:03 PM	#2
Boromir88 Laconic Loreman Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: USA Posts: 7,521	I would argue that the meaning behind Elrond's, "...you that travel with him no oath or bond holds you to go further then you will". That's only talking about the members to continue to travel with Frodo. There was no oath that the members of the fellowship had to continue to travel with Frodo. However, I would say there was an oath that as long as a member stayed in the Fellowship, he had to protect Frodo, and help him on his quest. Sam's line refers to Boromir breaking that oath, to protect Frodo. The scene in the movies with all the members stepping in to join Frodo, is surely an oath to help him. Aragorn: If by my life or death I can protect you I will! You have my sword! blah blah blah...everyone else comes in. Elrond's little phrase only ment the members didn't have to continue to travel with Frodo, as the line says. Last edited by Boromir88; 03-03-2005 at 06:06 PM.

03-03-2005, 10:13 AM	#1
alatar Doubting Dwimmerlaik Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Heaven's basement Posts: 2,466	From memory, when leaving Rivendell Gimli proposes that they all take an oath. Someone (Elrond?) says that this might not be a good idea as no one can foresee what will happen along the way. Gimli counters that an oath may 'buck up' one's resolve when things get tough. In the end I think that no one makes a formal declaration. Again if I remember correctly Aragorn says the line regarding "if by my life or death I can save you" or something to Frodo, but this may have been in Bree. The Boromir thing from Sam doesn't sound right.