The two UT's?!? What is the book that I have then?

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

I guess I am a little sensitive because I was taught that it was a character weakness not to finish a book and still feel a little guilty if I don't (unless the book is utter tripe) but while reading all sequentially may well be ideal if you are up to the task, I just wanted to emphasize that it is worth looking at the later volumes even if you are daunted by the early ones.

I've now got a notion to sit and read all the volumes in order, although I must have already done this to some extent with the early volumes many years ago as I used to religiously visit the Tolkien shelf in the local library and snap up anything I hadn't seen before. I'd like to see if it gave me the sense of a 'story' of the creation of Tolkien's life work.

But I still say that if reading all the volumes is daunting - and it may well be so for anyone quite new to Tolkien - then it is well worth beginning in the middle with those relating to LotR. And some of the volumes do include 'stand-alone' pieces, such as The New Shadow, set in the fourth age.

Now, while I was never taught it was a weakness not to finish a book, I do feel guilty if I don't at least give a book a chance. Even if I only read a random chapter I would call that giving it a chance. If the rest of the book is not useful, interesting or entertaining then I'm afraid I move on, as there are far too many books waiting to be read. I also have a nasty habit of skim-reading factual books, looking for the parts I need to read, a habit picked up from work. Maybe one of the reasons I like Tolkien so much is that skim-reading is out of the question; it's all too easy to miss something.

[eowyntje]

Wow, a lot of books.
Thanks a lot Mithalwen and Estelyn, for that information.
I'm reading the Sil right now and I hope I'll get my hand son the unfinished tales soon.

[Mithalwen]

Ah but Lal ....I was also taught that "only a woman of ill-repute would read a novel before lunch" (that one didn't register though .... ) and "a lounge is something they have in Hotels, darling" ... (which did and causes frequent verbal contortions)...

But certainly, despite my struggles with the early volumes, I found that the LOTR HoME volumes a relatively strightforward read.

I skim factual books if I need something specific.....but it took me many years to trust my judgement and accept that if a book hadn't engaged me (and I do give them a fair shot) and have very wide tastes) then I didn't have to waste my life finishing them.

[Thinlómien]

Thanks