Middle Earth AirForce

[Kuruharan]

Elrond should have realized that if trying to get rid of an unwelcome suitor for his daughter by sending him on a highly dangerous mission with 0.00001% chance of success didn't work for Thingol, it probably wasn't going to work for him either.

Yeah, but Aragorn actually did not go to Mordor, he actually took a much safer route. Notice how Aragorn weaseled out of the original plan. It was very "convenient" that Frodo and Sam left before Aragorn got to the shore, and that Pippin and Merry had been "kidnapped." He certainly did not waste much time in deciding to "rescue" Pippin and Merry rather than go after Frodo and Sam. The whole thing seems fishy.

(This thread has gotten silly.)