Tol-in-Gaurhoth IV (The Saga, erm, Still Continues...)

[Firefoot]

I agree with what Fea said in post 375. My real suspicion against Evisse right now is complete lack of suspicion on the part of anyone else. I am about 95% sure that she is our wolf.

I am not particularly for the idea of a double lynching (mostly because I am still fairly confident that lmp is innocent). I can see the logic of doing so, though, so if everyone else is for it, I guess I'm in.

I do think that we should be taking Ang's last words with a grain of salt: the only two that he absolutely cleared are Celuien and Saurreg. Beyond that, his speculations are about as trustworthy as any of ours. While I am inclined to accept Lalaith's innocence, we cannot absolutely discount her.

The other thing is, Evisse, you have been launching a "don't lynch me, don't lynch me!" campaign, but you have not told us who you think should be lynched and why...

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Betcha it's me.

Because I'm spear-heading the kill-Evisse campaign. But that's not what she'll say. It's probably have something to do with me being fickle, never being right, and being a constant confusion.

[Evisse the Blue]

The other thing is, Evisse, you have been launching a "don't lynch me, don't lynch me!" campaign, but you have not told us who you think should be lynched and why...

I am not starting an 'don't lynch me campaign'. Here's what I said in my first post today:

I won't make too much of a fuss to stop it. I realize I have it coming for being so wrong in my remarks about Anguirel. And even if an innocent is lynched today, the villagers still have the numerical advantage needed to win, if they use what evidence they have wisely.

I started interfering (and who can blame me for staying out of a debate? surely not the rest of you, people) when Saurreg suggested to have more than one lynching. I did not offer any judgements because I cannot guarantee you I'm gonna reach a logical conclusion. I have made one big mistake so far not recognizing the Seer and you'll understand that I don't want to make such a mistake again when the village is so close of getting rid of werewolves once and for all.
I am however at the moment most suspicious of Feanor (based on the same defensive reaction that Anguirel used against me, so if you're gonna buy that as being sound, you have no reason to doubt mine) and Lalaith for reasons stated many times before (and not only by me).

Betcha it's me.
Because I'm spear-heading the kill-Evisse campaign. But that's not what she'll say. It's probably have something to do with me being fickle, never being right, and being a constant confusion.

And would I not be completely right in saying so?
But I have a feeling you won't be leading the campaign against me for long. As soon as the votes for me gather, you'll start picking on someone else. And this is because you'll realize you're wrong, and you hate people telling you that you're wrong.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

But I have a feeling you won't be leading the campaign against me for long. As soon as the votes for me gather, you'll start picking on someone else. And this is because you'll realize you're wrong, and you hate people telling you that you're wrong.

Hey, give me some credit! I haven't spear-headed or bandwagoned anyone yet. As soon as the votes for you gather, I'll be extremely relieved. Once you die and I find out the truth, I'll either sigh with relief and start accepting compliments, or I'll sigh with secondary relief and proffer myself to the village as sacrifice for screwing up royally. I doubt the latter need happen though, since I doubt I'm wrong about you.

Although... I'm starting to wonder if you are the Gifted one, and not someone else. It would explain why you interfered at mention of a double-lynching... if you died, as well as someone you didn't suspect, AND you thought you might be wrong on whoever is most recently on your kill-list... You'd hate to see three possibly-innocents die.

[littlemanpoet]

Originally Posted by Lalaith

We are now thanks to Anguirel, fortunate enough to have three proven innocents: Saurreg, Celuien and myself...

Originally Posted by Anguirel

Lalaith I could still be wrong about, which would be irritating. But I'm genuinely taken in by her mathematical hopelessness and apparent honesty, not to mention the entente cordiale we seem to have formed.

I conjecture that my post #371, though posted almost 45 minutes before Lalaith's post # 372, escaped her notice and that there may have been cross-posting. How else could she blithely have claimed innocence based on the faulty reasoning previous to my post?

Allow me to be clear and concise: Anguirel did not declare Lalaith innocent. Rather, he had a hunch that he really wanted to believe, and would have been very irritated were he wrong. So if Lalaith is the final werewolf, and we foolishly assume her innocence based on the faulty reading mentioned above, we lose.

I find it more than a little worrying that Lalaith has been so quick to follow up the misunderstanding of Anguirel's words by claiming innocence that has in fact not been proven. Does this make Lal the final werewolf? No, but it sure does make her suspicious, especially if we add in her typical failure to account for cross posting, mathematics, and other such mis-steps. She is suddenly looking a lot more suspicious to me than Evisse, and even a little more suspicious to me than Feanor.

So I'm asking all of you to reconsider your current spear-heading against Evisse and take a closer look at Lalaith. I'm not trying to protect Evisse, either. I'm going with the evidence instead, same as yesterday.

Oh, and Lalaith, this would be a good time to offer what defense you can ... if you can. ::LMP looks her way with narrowed eyes::

[Evisse the Blue]

No, I'm not a gifted villager. Since I'll be lynched today anyway, and this will be revealed, I might as well say it. That great responsibility is not laid on me, fortunately (or unfortunately).
You want to know who I'd go after if I were, though? Lalaith. I am so taken aback by the fact that none of you suspect her, though, that I'm starting to doubt the clarity of my judgement.

EDIT: Cross posting with lmp. So I'm not completely mad yet.