Notice Board for - Midsummer Maulings (Moderated by Mithalwen) - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Mithalwen · 07-09-2005, 11:50 AM

The Cassandra Award goes to Kitanna

Unjustly maligned and suspected, to my mind she was a superb seer. She picked Kath as the Mythomaniac on the first night and Mormegil as a wolf on the second. she was already suspected by the time she was able to try and communicate this and so probably feared to be more explicit.

While TGWBS got the right strategy it was after he had voted for Kitanna.. so he gets the Baldrick Award for his cunning plan with a fatal flaw. He also gets a bonus prize for the most enjoyable characterisation

Gil Galad gets the Lazarus Award for his return to the fray which added to much amusement again. Also managed to play the role of the hunter without seeming to really understand it!!!!

Fea gets the Mandelson Award for Spin Doctoring. I have to say she is a player who rises to the occasion. If I catch her playing like a loon I will know she is a humble villager! Love the way she drew attention to Gil's substitution while eliding the simialar reasons for her own.

Holbytlass gets the Capatain Oates Award for (attempted) noble self sacrifice. It could have turned the game.

I have to go almost immediately but just time for one further award -
The Svengali Award goes to Morm - I spluttered into my lunch as I realised that second night that:

Durelin wanted to protect Mormegil
Kitanna wanted to dream about Mormegil
Kath wanted to be Mormegil

Mithalwen btw had to be very careful
not to answer Mormegil's all so reasonable questions .....

Hypnotic charisma - I was seriusly freaked.

Many thanks to you all - it was an interesting game. My poor lab rats...all gone

Post Mortem tomorrow

07-09-2005, 11:50 AM	#31
Mithalwen Pilgrim Soul Join Date: May 2004 Location: watching the wonga-wonga birds circle... Posts: 9,461	The 'M-ies' s - Award Ceremony (pt 1) The Cassandra Award goes to Kitanna Unjustly maligned and suspected, to my mind she was a superb seer. She picked Kath as the Mythomaniac on the first night and Mormegil as a wolf on the second. she was already suspected by the time she was able to try and communicate this and so probably feared to be more explicit. While TGWBS got the right strategy it was after he had voted for Kitanna.. so he gets the Baldrick Award for his cunning plan with a fatal flaw. He also gets a bonus prize for the most enjoyable characterisation Gil Galad gets the Lazarus Award for his return to the fray which added to much amusement again. Also managed to play the role of the hunter without seeming to really understand it!!!! Fea gets the Mandelson Award for Spin Doctoring. I have to say she is a player who rises to the occasion. If I catch her playing like a loon I will know she is a humble villager! Love the way she drew attention to Gil's substitution while eliding the simialar reasons for her own. Holbytlass gets the Capatain Oates Award for (attempted) noble self sacrifice. It could have turned the game. I have to go almost immediately but just time for one further award - The Svengali Award goes to Morm - I spluttered into my lunch as I realised that second night that: Durelin wanted to protect Mormegil Kitanna wanted to dream about Mormegil Kath wanted to be Mormegil Mithalwen btw had to be very careful not to answer Mormegil's all so reasonable questions ..... Hypnotic charisma - I was seriusly freaked. Many thanks to you all - it was an interesting game. My poor lab rats...all gone Post Mortem tomorrow __________________ “But Finrod walks with Finarfin his father beneath the trees in Eldamar.” Christopher Tolkien, Requiescat in pace