Could it have worked?

[The Only Real Estel]

I must admit that, although I didn't like the fact or the events surrounding it, I found the Hopeless Charge (Faramir to Osgiliath) to be a very sentimental scene. Especially with Pippin's little "All Shall Fade" number.

I like that part also (strategy notwithstanding ). It's not really Osgiliath in general that I thought was bad, just most of the Osgiliath screen time in TTT (hence this thread ).