‘Canonicity’: the Book or the Reader?

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by SpM

Even if they wish to do so, they have no control over the reader's honest reaction to the work. They may have influence, but they have no control.

Now, as a parent, wouldn't you say that exerting an influence is a form of control? It may be control in a velvet glove, but it is still done to direct and to steer away from what is seen as the wrong path?

And having an influence can also depend upon who has that influence. If it is someone with status, then they are able to exert greater pressure than those who have little status. As I've said in the other C thread, you may well retain the right to do or say something but if nobody wants to listen or you do not have the means to express yourself then it is of little consequence.