Werewolf IIX - Tra la la lally, here down in the Saga, ha ha!

[wilwarin538]

...can the Seer reveal the Bear?

Yes, I believe s(he) can, its the Cobbler they can't reveal is it not?

[Oddwen]

Yes.

[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by wilwarin538

So, who would want to kill Alcarillo?

Well, Alcarillo voted for Mithalwen, so that doesn't help. Other than her, he voiced suspicions of Gurthang and LMP. But that was early on, when most others were thinking along the same lines, so it doesn't really take us much further either. Laitaine voted for Alcarillo but, unless she is going for a bold double-bluff, it would seem rather clumsy for the Bear to kill, on Night 2, the person he or she voted for on Day 1.

Unfortunately, I suspect that we will need an incredible stroke of fortune to bag the Bear during the first few Days. Still, we have a number of possible candidates for the other two Wolves. I outlined my top suspects earlier. I would particularly like to hear from Gil-Galad, Durelin and Laitaine.

Edit: Cross-posted with Gil-Galad. Correction - I would like to hear more from him.

[Gil-Galad]

Usually i hate decisons, but i was rather rushed and in my haste voted for Gurthang, when i read back later in the day, my suspiscon turned to Mithalwen, bu alas it was too late, she was already voted out and to my(and the rest of the village) she was a werewolf, also i didn't intentionally vote for Gurthang to tie up the votes for Mithalwen, as i said before, Gurthang seemed like the more likely culprit

[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Gil-Galad

Usually i hate decisons, but i was rather rushed and in my haste voted for Gurthang, when i read back later in the day, my suspiscon turned to Mithalwen, bu alas it was too late ...

Well there was nothing said after you voted that made Mithalwen seem any more or less supicious than she already was, save for the fact that the votes against her accumulated. The basis upon which I suspect most voted for her was already there before you voted. Do you mean that you did not read what had been said up to that point when you voted? If so, it would surely have been better to wait until you had a chance to do so before voting.

Originally Posted by Gil-Galad

... also i didn't intentionally vote for Gurthang to tie up the votes for Mithalwen, as i said before, Gurthang seemed like the more likely culprit

Yet you posted the number of votes that had been cast up to that point when you voted, so you clearly knew that you would bring them to a tie.

I'm sorry, Gil, but I really don't buy your explanation. For the time being, you remain at the top of my suspect list.

[Gil-Galad]

Well to be honest, i really never read much of it, i just skim through and whichever seems more reasonable i go with...so most of my votes aren't really how i feel......now you don't know what to do

[Meneltarmacil]

Gil, thou verily didst not give muche of a reasone for thy decisione, all thou saidst was that thy reasons had already been stated by other people. As ye reasons given were only because of an in-character commente that had been misinterpreted (this had been mentioned by ye time thou posted), I suspecte thou hidest thy true reasone.

And my commente about ye guillotine was merely a bit of in-game joking arounde, Captain.

[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Gil-Galad

Well to be honest, i really never read much of it, i just skim through and whichever seems more reasonable i go with...so most of my votes aren't really how i feel

Hmm, if you are a Wolf I would have expected a much more spirited defence than this. Funnily enough, your flimsy defence makes me suspect you less. But, for now, you remain within my sights.

Originally Posted by Gil-Galad

......now you don't know what to do

Do any of us, really? The Wolves' knowledge is the most complete and yet there are gaps in that which we may be able to exploit to our profit.

Durelin, your long post confirms my suspicions of you. You say a lot, but you are not really 'saying' anything - well, nothing which has not been said already.

And I feel that we need to hear more from Encaitare, wilwarin538 and Laitaine. We have killed one loud Wolf. Perhaps the other two are more the silent type ...