Werewolf IIX - Tra la la lally, here down in the Saga, ha ha! - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

arcticstorm · 08-17-2005, 07:19 AM

After hearing of today's deaths I have reviewed everything said by the four killed at night. I will start by listing what was said, suspicion-wise, by the wolf victims, and then will move to the bear victims.

Morm's first list of suspicions points to Firefoot, Mithalwen, and myself. The next time he voices suspicion, he changes it to Samwise, CoD and Mith. Later he voices suspicion of anyone who voted for Mith, in case she was innocent, with special interest on Menel and Alcarillo. He then votes for Meneltarmacil. He was probably killed for his role in bringing out Mith.

Firefoot: On Day one she was only really suspicious of Mithalwen and voted for him.
On the second day, she originally posted a little suspicion or confusion toward Gil, Durelin, Nonnac. Laitaine, and Wilwa.
Later she became mionorly suspicios of CoD. With her list being Durelin, Gil, Lalaith, CoD, and Nonnacedak.
And later points out that Gurthang may be the bear.
She votes for Durelin as wolf, because there are too many people who could be the bear.

On to the Bear victims.
Alcarillo: voiced minor suspicion of Gurthang but more toward LMP. Later he put Mith on the top of the list and voted for him. NOt much to go on there yet, but I will examine it further with Enca's suspicions later. He ended up by voting for a Mithalwen.

Enca: On Day 1 she voiced suspicion of Gurthang early on, and didn't say much else for the rest of the day
On day 2: Post suspicion of LMP being a wolf. She becomes suspicious of Gil and votes for Gil. She may have beeen killed for her contributions shortly after the day was half over, but let us look at that closer.

Alcarillo's next suspect was LMP, he got himself killed.
Enca also voices some suspicion of LMP and gets herself killed by the bear. This may be a coincidence or it may be someone trying to frame LMP. Or maybe LMP is the bear. Yes Enca voiced suspicion of him being a wolf, but if people vote to kill him of wolvery, he still dies wether he is a wolf or a bear.

Right now my wolf suspicion list is Durelin first followed by Gil
and LMP heads up my bear suspicion list.

Lalaith · 08-17-2005, 07:30 AM

At this stage I also think both wolves and bear are killing those who are not under strong suspicion from the village. The reasoning being that they wouldn't bother killing off people that the villagers might lynch for them anyway.

Gil-Galad · 08-17-2005, 07:42 AM

i would have to agree with Lailaith there, the Wolves/bear are hitting people off that aren't big on suspicon.... oh yeah, Hear ye Hear Ye, Firefoot and Enca have both been deceased, were running out of graves, more news at 11!

Edit: also yesterday, i totally forgot to vote when i got back home, i'll try to remember today(think to, i usually have to vote early...)

littlemanpoet · 08-17-2005, 12:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by arcticstorm

On to the Bear victims.
Alcarillo: voiced minor suspicion of Gurthang but more toward LMP. Later he put Mith on the top of the list and voted for him. NOt much to go on there yet, but I will examine it further with Enca's suspicions later. He ended up by voting for a Mithalwen.

Enca: On Day 1 she voiced suspicion of Gurthang early on, and didn't say much else for the rest of the day
On day 2: Post suspicion of LMP being a wolf. She becomes suspicious of Gil and votes for Gil. She may have beeen killed for her contributions shortly after the day was half over, but let us look at that closer.

Alcarillo's next suspect was LMP, he got himself killed.
Enca also voices some suspicion of LMP and gets herself killed by the bear. This may be a coincidence or it may be someone trying to frame LMP. Or maybe LMP is the bear. Yes Enca voiced suspicion of him being a wolf, but if people vote to kill him of wolvery, he still dies wether he is a wolf or a bear.

Right now my wolf suspicion list is Durelin first followed by Gil
and LMP heads up my bear suspicion list.

I'd like everyone to be aware that I did not read this post until after I submitted my own first of the day. Quite interesting, Arcticstorm, building up a trumped up case like this, looking for all the world like you're doing in depth analysis while only using others' words to build your own case. You are getting all the more suspicious. I won't vote for you just yet, want to read through all the posts first.

Meneltarmacil · 08-17-2005, 01:34 PM

After reading Boromir88's posts, I only finde a fewe clues that woulde hinte at what he is. He accuseth Gurthang on ye firste Daye due to ye in-character commente, then voteth for Mithalwen after Gil-Galad, putting her in firste place. That woulde hinte that he is at leaste not a Wolfe.

On ye seconde Daye, he pointeth out differente people as suspects, then leapeth on ye bandwagon for CaptainofDespair following Ye Saucepan Man's suspicions. His vote is ye one that putteth Captain in ye majority. He seemeth to not saye a whole lot, but goeth along with ye moste suspiciouse people at ye time. He mighte be ye Beare, but it is harde to telle ye Beare aparte from an Ordinary Villager, at leaste harder than it is to telle a Wolfe aparte. I finde him a little suspiciouse, but all I can saye is that he is probably not a Wolfe. I don'te have many leads to go on righte now.

08-17-2005, 07:19 AM	#1
arcticstorm Shade of Carn Dûm Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Johnson Bible College: Knoxville, TN Posts: 464	After hearing of today's deaths I have reviewed everything said by the four killed at night. I will start by listing what was said, suspicion-wise, by the wolf victims, and then will move to the bear victims. Morm's first list of suspicions points to Firefoot, Mithalwen, and myself. The next time he voices suspicion, he changes it to Samwise, CoD and Mith. Later he voices suspicion of anyone who voted for Mith, in case she was innocent, with special interest on Menel and Alcarillo. He then votes for Meneltarmacil. He was probably killed for his role in bringing out Mith. Firefoot: On Day one she was only really suspicious of Mithalwen and voted for him. On the second day, she originally posted a little suspicion or confusion toward Gil, Durelin, Nonnac. Laitaine, and Wilwa. Later she became mionorly suspicios of CoD. With her list being Durelin, Gil, Lalaith, CoD, and Nonnacedak. And later points out that Gurthang may be the bear. She votes for Durelin as wolf, because there are too many people who could be the bear. On to the Bear victims. Alcarillo: voiced minor suspicion of Gurthang but more toward LMP. Later he put Mith on the top of the list and voted for him. NOt much to go on there yet, but I will examine it further with Enca's suspicions later. He ended up by voting for a Mithalwen. Enca: On Day 1 she voiced suspicion of Gurthang early on, and didn't say much else for the rest of the day On day 2: Post suspicion of LMP being a wolf. She becomes suspicious of Gil and votes for Gil. She may have beeen killed for her contributions shortly after the day was half over, but let us look at that closer. Alcarillo's next suspect was LMP, he got himself killed. Enca also voices some suspicion of LMP and gets herself killed by the bear. This may be a coincidence or it may be someone trying to frame LMP. Or maybe LMP is the bear. Yes Enca voiced suspicion of him being a wolf, but if people vote to kill him of wolvery, he still dies wether he is a wolf or a bear. Right now my wolf suspicion list is Durelin first followed by Gil and LMP heads up my bear suspicion list. Last edited by arcticstorm; 08-17-2005 at 08:03 AM. Reason: grammatical error

08-17-2005, 07:30 AM	#2
Lalaith Blithe Spirit Join Date: Jan 2003 Posts: 2,779	At this stage I also think both wolves and bear are killing those who are not under strong suspicion from the village. The reasoning being that they wouldn't bother killing off people that the villagers might lynch for them anyway. __________________ Out went the candle, and we were left darkling

08-17-2005, 07:42 AM	#3
Gil-Galad Psyche of Prince Immortal Join Date: Feb 2003 Location: Above a Parapet Obvious exits are: North, South, and Dennis Posts: 4,734	i would have to agree with Lailaith there, the Wolves/bear are hitting people off that aren't big on suspicon.... oh yeah, Hear ye Hear Ye, Firefoot and Enca have both been deceased, were running out of graves, more news at 11! Edit: also yesterday, i totally forgot to vote when i got back home, i'll try to remember today(think to, i usually have to vote early...) __________________ Love doesn't blow up and get killed.

08-17-2005, 01:34 PM	#5
Meneltarmacil Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: The bottom of the ocean, discussing philosophy with a giant squid Posts: 2,254	After reading Boromir88's posts, I only finde a fewe clues that woulde hinte at what he is. He accuseth Gurthang on ye firste Daye due to ye in-character commente, then voteth for Mithalwen after Gil-Galad, putting her in firste place. That woulde hinte that he is at leaste not a Wolfe. On ye seconde Daye, he pointeth out differente people as suspects, then leapeth on ye bandwagon for CaptainofDespair following Ye Saucepan Man's suspicions. His vote is ye one that putteth Captain in ye majority. He seemeth to not saye a whole lot, but goeth along with ye moste suspiciouse people at ye time. He mighte be ye Beare, but it is harde to telle ye Beare aparte from an Ordinary Villager, at leaste harder than it is to telle a Wolfe aparte. I finde him a little suspiciouse, but all I can saye is that he is probably not a Wolfe. I don'te have many leads to go on righte now. __________________ I ♣ baby seals.