Ring driven or Meat Driven?

[CaptainofDespair]

Originally Posted by Glirdan

It's quite alright. We're all entitled to our own opinions. Yet now I would have to agree with you Eomer and Kitanna. I would have rathered the Ents as they were in the book over Pippin outsmating one of the oldest beings of all of Middle Earth. It would have been better if they just went by how Grishnahk and Pippin acted in the books.

In that case, they should have just made the movies exactly like the books.

I'd prefer Clever Grish, but I can see why a Hungry Grish would be better for a mass-audience movie. I'd also prefer Book Treebeard over Movie, but again...it's for that accursed audience.