Werewolf IX: the Saga Owns You and You Know It

[Cailín]

Soo *is feeling loud today*

Originally Posted by Wilwarin

I think we should look at what Saucy posted here:

I'm not too sure. All SpM's theories were more or less based on the assumption that Azaelia was a wolf. But she wasn't.

I agree with a bit of this. Though for me I would switch Menel's name to Top suspects, Shelob to I don't knows and Holby I feel is innocent. Folwren also to Top suspects.

But why? Referring to speculations is not really enough right now. Why Menel, because he voted for Azaelia? May I remind you, you did the same. As did many others, almost all of us thought she was guilty. Why do you feel Holby is innocent? And what about Folwren?

I realize I'm all over you here, but we need some opinions and if you are a wolf I am very much trying to catch you off-guard, of course ^^. In the same post Saucy says you're cleared if Azaelia is a wolf, but you're not. You are one of those who have voted for three known innocents in a row, disregarding your vote for Glirdan who might have been an innocent for all you know or care, if you are indeed a wolf.

So mine would be:

Top suspects: Meneltarmacil, Folwren
Secondary suspects: Kath, Gil-Galad
Don’t knows: Cailín, Durelin and WaynetheGoblin, Shelob
Probably not Wolves: Holbytlass
Definitely innocent: Nilpaurion and wilwarin538

Fair enough.

Mine:

Top suspects: Shelob, Kath
Secondary suspects: Wilwa, Wayne, Holby
Don't knows: Menel, Durelin, Gil
Probably not a wolf: Folwren
Definitely innocent: Nilp, myself

But am reconsidering every post