LOTR Survivor - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

malkatoj · 09-26-2005, 03:58 PM

(Sorry about joining this thread so late in it, I just discovered it. Hope I don't mess anything up too horribly.)

I think that Galadriel clearly needs to die, simply because of her movie portrayal. Sure, she's an elf and has magical...talents, I guess. But nobody should be able to speak without moving her mouth. Because of this habit, she always looks like she's about to eat the other characters, and for some reason I wouldn't be particularly surprised if that happened. Adding to this that she gave Frodo the light...which allowed Sam to make a fool of himself while trying to get rid of Shelob...it was a generally bad idea and they would have gotten more use out of something like 'more food'. For these reasons, I cast my vote for

++Galadriel

09-26-2005, 03:58 PM	#17
malkatoj Wight Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: A hovel in Florin Posts: 173	(Sorry about joining this thread so late in it, I just discovered it. Hope I don't mess anything up too horribly.) I think that Galadriel clearly needs to die, simply because of her movie portrayal. Sure, she's an elf and has magical...talents, I guess. But nobody should be able to speak without moving her mouth. Because of this habit, she always looks like she's about to eat the other characters, and for some reason I wouldn't be particularly surprised if that happened. Adding to this that she gave Frodo the light...which allowed Sam to make a fool of himself while trying to get rid of Shelob...it was a generally bad idea and they would have gotten more use out of something like 'more food'. For these reasons, I cast my vote for ++Galadriel