Welcome to Tol-in-Gauroth XI 'Fall of the Fall'

[mormegil]

Originally Posted by SpM

Hmm. Who's top of that list, I wonder?

Bottom of the list now, but the only one remaining from the previous list - just so as to reinforce the suggestion

My lists have been in no particular order.

I would be interested, morm, if you would cite some examples. To the extent that I did act any differently, it was because (following Cailin's continued strong accusation of Eomer and his attack on her) I became certain of Eomer's guilt and therefore acted accordingly.

One was the assertion of how innocent you are. I know you've explained it but it still seemed odd to me. Another was your most recent post. Why such a strong defense when there has been no attack? The only possible people I could see that would want to defend themselves so emphatically are gifteds and wolves. And I know that you are not a gifted. An innocent shouldn't be so concerned about self-defense. Also your stong defense was interesting because it came after I said this today.

I think this shows one thing and only one thing. SpM was innocent to begin with. It doesn't mean that he didn't turn wolf the other night. Again I want to emphasize that I am not certain that my wacky theory has any merit but I think that we need to recognize that it's possible.

I admit it's a bit far-fetched but possible and I want people to recognize that you are not exonerated simply because you were key in Eomer's lynching. I wasn't anticipating having a showdown with you today, but you are seeming rather intent on it. I must ask myself why? I can't say that what I said about my theory was very offensive so again why are you so defensive?