Welcome to Tol-in-Gauroth XI 'Fall of the Fall'

[The Saucepan Man]

OK. I am thinking of doing something which may seem a little bit strange.

Having seen the votes mount up for wilwarin, it occurs to me that a lot would be learned from her death. If she is lynched and found to be guilty, all well and fine. But, if she is lynched and found to be innocent, then those who have pushed for her lynching to-Day look very suspicious. Indeed, the final two Wolves will almost certainly be among them. That would put Formendacil and arcticstorm in the frame, with mormegil's guilt or innocence being established to-Morrow when either he or Abercrombie is lynched (and both die).

With the mormegil-Abercrombie Hunter dispute, we have been handed a Wolf on a plate. We have one in the bag, as it were. However, the final Wolf was (or, if wilwa is innocent, the final two Wolves were) always going to be more difficult to find.

So, my proposal is as follows. We lynch wilwarin to-Day. I believe her to be guilty and, if she is, that's fine. In that case, I believe that arcticstorm and, in particular, Formendacil can be pretty much crossed off the Wolf list. If, on the other hand, she is innocent, I would pin them both as the Wolves (with either mormegil or Abercrombie being the other).

The only possible problem here is that if either Formendacil or arctistorm is a Wolf who has written off both wilwarin and mormegil/Abercrombie (whichever is the Wolf) and decided to go it alone. But we hit that problem anyway, even if we lynch mormegil to-Day and leave wilwarin until to-Morrow.

So I am toying with the idea of voting for wilwarin. That will not seal her fate, because there will then be on 4 votes each and morm, with the first vote of the Day, will be lynched. And I have doubts whether Alcarillo will turn up to vote. But if that happens, fine. We know that we will catch a Wolf one way or another if mormegil is lynched.

Thoughts anyone?