WWJ II: Welcome to Lower Tadfield. The Apocalypse has Now Begun.

[Kitanna]

Here comes a double post!

Originally Posted by tar-ancalime

With so many abstentions, I'm tempted to think that at least one wolf didn't vote. Good way to stay under the radar, not leave a trail, eh?

I agree and disagree with this. I admit it is a good way for wolves to stay under the rador and at least one wolf probably did not vote, but it is also very dangerous so I doubt today the wolf (if one of those people is a wolf) will miss voting again.

Now onto what I gathered from Gurthang.

Post #6 Gurthang throw out DEATH and Wayne as suspects. Clearly just baseless accussations based on previous games and occupations. Not much to be gained there.

Post #14 he comments on Glirdan's Eonwe trust. Is the first to bring up the odds being against Eonwe to be a wolf two times in a row. Also says wolves will stay away from being too loud or too quiet.

Post #16 he calls out tar on her plan of "refraining to accuse innocents". He encourages everyone to "let the accusations and defenses fly".

Post #22 calls out tar again on her jumpiness and flip-flopping. Suggests a possible Eonwe/Tar wolf strategy. Says though it is probably unlikely.

Post #34 Not much in this post. Talks about Eonwe's chances of being a wolf again. Responds to SR's problems with random, baseless accussations, saying it is a good way to start day one.

Post #37 continues to defend (if that be the right word) his reasons for suspecting Eonwe less.

Post #47 Asks for reasons from Rune and Glirdan why they suspect who they do. Mentions Glirdan and Tar as suspects. Also mentions DEATH but not in an accussing way.

Post #61 votes for DEATH.

So what can we gather from this? Well, one way to look at it is that the wolves killed Gurthang because he was no one near getting one of them and they wanted to frame up someone else. If that is the case they were trying to fram up tar or possibly Eonwe because those two Gurthang mentioned most.

Or Gurthang was hitting close to home. Which again would point to tar and Eonwe. And they figured they could fake out the village and claim a frame up. I think both theories are equally likely.