Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIII: Enter Shamville

[littlemanpoet]

Originally Posted by Eonwe

hmm well there are a couple situations that arrise from your said plan, LMP.:

we could pick an innocent to lead us, which would yeild two resolts:

1) lynching of a wolf. that wold be good and our leader would be praised.
2) lynchin of an innocent. that would be bad, not only because we killed an innocent, but because we now cast suspicion on yet annother innocent. not to mention we wouldn't get anything as way of a trail.

or we could pick a wolf to lead us, also yeilding two results:

1) the wolf chooses to lynch a wolf. that is good and bad. we kill a wolf, but clear a wolf as well.
2) he lynches an innocent. good because we would suspet him.

all in all, i think it could be a worthy plan. but we should use it later on. and don't ellect me as leader, either.

You analysis, good sir, is quite on target. And having read it, I must say that you have unveiled a fatal flaw in it, unless you can convince me otherwise. That fatal flaw is none other than the wolf leader choosing to lynch a wolf, thus more or less clearing self of suspicion. Of course, 'tis not a fatal flaw if we all go in realizing that a wolf may just be forced by the plan to pick a fellow wolf for lynching; but the question is, would a wolf do such a thing so early in the game? The late and dear departed Fea might, but she is no longer with us, gods rest her soul, big as its head was. All that to say, maybe it is therefore not such a fatal flaw, and still gives us two votes per Day rather than just one. More opinions?

Of course, the plan's merit has already been a little washed out for toDay with Bergil's early vote. So early! That is, of course, suspicious, though he gives a reason; but his reason has holes, if you know what I mean; after all, everyone knew each other's professions before Spawn's death; making his supposed reason mere empty air.