Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIII: Enter Shamville

[Firefoot]

LMP, I do think you might be on to something. tar's post is very cool, almost too smooth, now that I read it again. A brilliant example of taking others' ideas and running with them, expanding, being "helpful." She has now moved up on my suspect list.

So, if tar was a wolf, who else might be wolves? At most one of Lalaith, LMP, Ang, and Wilwa would be a wolf, quite possibly none. Even though she states Lalaith is the least suspicious of those to her, she spends a lot of time in her post going over them. LMP, I am not too concerned about. Possibly Ang or Wilwa, but nothing certain there.

Firefoot and Kitanna have posted detailed analyses of yesterDAY's posting and voting; I'm thankful for both of these posts and since I tend to think that both of them are innocent, I eagerly await more posts like these.

Knowing my own innocence (I don't expect any of you to trust me on this, of course), I would guess that if tar is a wolf, Kitanna is not. This fits with my earlier statement that Kitanna seemed pretty safe to me (still does, after going through toDay's posts). If there was a wolf among her stated innocents, I think it would be Glirdan, but I'm becoming less suspicious of him as the Day goes on. This is not an in-depth statement, I haven't studied much too closely yet, but a surface-level feeling.

That leaves Wayne, Eonwe, Menel, Kath, and Celuien. Even if tar weren't a wolf, I don't think I'd be surprised if a wolf came off this list, and if she is a wolf, I think one almost certainly would. Kath and Celuien have thus far seemed pretty innocent to me. Wayne, I don't know how anyone could get any kind of reading from him. Eonwe and Menel are both in between very suspicious and the halfway point.

So currently my suspicion list looks something like this:

Tar
Menel
Eonwe
Wayne
Ang
Glirdan
Wilwa

Note: this has been largely off the cuff and unresearched. I still have not gone over Day 2 in depth. I will be doing that before I go to bed, and very likely voting in a similar time-frame as yesterDay.

Cross-posting with a lot of people...