Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIV: Nyárë Nauroron Númenoreva

[Formendacil]

Originally Posted by Fordim Hedgethistle

Not revenge so much as payback, m’lad. So far, Formy’s been getting something of a free pass and the only one as has been pointing a finger at him is now lynched…and a proven innocent, I might add removing any tint of wolfishness from his accusations.

Well, I would agree with you that the "proven innocent" thing, as nice as it is, is possibly a little unfounded, thought true. As for the no one pointing a finger well... you appear to be doing just that, if somewhat cautiously.

I've got a question for our Mod, or possibly for one of our more experienced members, which I couldn't find the answer to in Post #1. It regards the Cobbler. Does the Cobbler appear as an Innocent to the Seer? My understanding was that he/she did... Furthermore, when he dies, do we find out right away that he/she was the Cobbler, or do we have to wait until Game End?

I've never played with a Cobbler before, so I'm curious...

My main thought is that if the Cobbler is kept secret until Game End, then we may have killed him (I still say that Gurthang acted Cobblerish, whether he was or not).

A secondary thought that occurred to me in the writing of this, was that if the Seer dreams of Cobblers as Innocents, then some assumptions about this village may be wrong.

I checked the first post of the thread for clarification, but didn't find any.