Tol-in-Gaurhoth XV-The Villagers Strike Back! - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Boromir88 · 12-22-2005, 07:23 AM

Why would a hero, trying to pass himself off as Carcharoth, claim he would "hunt for" the very person he tried to kill that night, knowing it was unsuccessful and the Ranger had protected that person?

If Farael was the fake Carcharoth, it just doesn't make sense to say he's going to kill the very person he unsuccessfully killed last night?

No, Farael's move does not seem like a fake Carcharoth, just a misled Carcharoth. Being Carcharoth he would have no idea that you protected Meneltarmacil, or that the Heroes went after him. It seems like Farael was acting on suspicions that Meneltarmacil had been hypocritical and switched from defending him, to now wanting to eat him.

If Farael was a hero in disguise of Carcharoth, I very much doubt he would chose to pick the same person they tried to whack last night. Just seems like Farael has been misguided and believed Menel was guilty, as we find out he's not and I tell Farael the same plan as I said in an earlier post. Go after Nonna, or Gurthang, whoever we don't eat. Though now it looks like we'll have a mass murder anyone unless someone breaks this tie.

12-22-2005, 07:23 AM	#11
Boromir88 Laconic Loreman Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: USA Posts: 7,521	Why would a hero, trying to pass himself off as Carcharoth, claim he would "hunt for" the very person he tried to kill that night, knowing it was unsuccessful and the Ranger had protected that person? If Farael was the fake Carcharoth, it just doesn't make sense to say he's going to kill the very person he unsuccessfully killed last night? No, Farael's move does not seem like a fake Carcharoth, just a misled Carcharoth. Being Carcharoth he would have no idea that you protected Meneltarmacil, or that the Heroes went after him. It seems like Farael was acting on suspicions that Meneltarmacil had been hypocritical and switched from defending him, to now wanting to eat him. If Farael was a hero in disguise of Carcharoth, I very much doubt he would chose to pick the same person they tried to whack last night. Just seems like Farael has been misguided and believed Menel was guilty, as we find out he's not and I tell Farael the same plan as I said in an earlier post. Go after Nonna, or Gurthang, whoever we don't eat. Though now it looks like we'll have a mass murder anyone unless someone breaks this tie. __________________ Fenris Penguin