Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island

[Gurthang]

Originally Posted by Kuruharan

I suppose it's something to keep in mind. However, I'm not sure a wolf would extend itself to save another when there are still three of them. I guess I'd feel more confident about that conclusion (if we should get to a point of testing it) if something else turned up.

I think they would. If they don't, then they lose a wolf on the first day, a major set-back. If they do, then we won't even know it was wolf saving wolf until we actually kill one (or both) of them. Sounds like something a wolf could, and very well would, do.

Nilp, I'm surprised you haven't suggested lynching Saucepan Man for being too smart. I'm leaning on number 4. It just seems like something you would do.

I'm inclined to think that Menel is innocent. He quickly called Kath's cobbler comment into open view. He might be a wolf, but I think it's a stretch that they would intentionally kill their teammate on the first Night. But on the other hand, everyone (assuming they saw Menel's commment), so the wolves would have known she had left the hint.

That being said, she must have said something else in order for them to kill her, something that maybe made them think she was a gifted rather than the cobbler. I'll go check.