Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Cailín · 01-12-2006, 01:03 AM

I’m rather surprised at all the reactions to the post in which I mentioned Kath’s odd choice of words! Surely, yes, I noticed and could have not missed it after Meneltarmacil pointed it out, but the ability to read hardly makes one wolvish. I hope more innocents here ‘know where to look for’, cause otherwise analyzing seems pretty pointless. Anyway - you might not believe me, but when I go over those other old werewolf-related legends two particular instants jump out in this respect. There was this one time when a traitor managed to ensure the slaughter of an entire village because no one picked up on the clues he left the villains. And there was another instant in which a certain wolf was too thick to pick up on some rather obvious choice-of-word clues, made a bad decision and was killed during the first Night. All in all, I try to catch these things as much as I can. Of course, this does not make me more or less guilty, just attempting to clarify something.

Such early votes from Alcarillo all the time! Yes - Kath indeed voiced some worries concerning me, but I felt it could hardly be called an accusation. I also wish to add that even though Naria and malkatoj have excuses for being bandwagon persons, Nilp was still the safest vote yesterday and I would not be surprised if there is a wolf - perhaps 2, not excluding Nilp himself - among those who voted for him. But then again, a wolf likely voted for Gil as well and yesterday was an excellent opportunity for wolf on wolf voting (and strangely enough Farael / Eluchil jump to mind). Gurthang has said it earlier - Eluchil is acting a bit strange, accusing everyone who has accused him, but then again, newbies often do.

I see Garin is a little less vocal today, Nilp is still talking in riddles and some people have yet to make an appearance. I think Menel is in the clear, with me, for now. I do not think he’d sacrifice such a valuable possible teammate as the Cobbler so easily.

01-12-2006, 01:03 AM	#11
Cailín Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Lurking in the shadows. Posts: 711	I’m rather surprised at all the reactions to the post in which I mentioned Kath’s odd choice of words! Surely, yes, I noticed and could have not missed it after Meneltarmacil pointed it out, but the ability to read hardly makes one wolvish. I hope more innocents here ‘know where to look for’, cause otherwise analyzing seems pretty pointless. Anyway - you might not believe me, but when I go over those other old werewolf-related legends two particular instants jump out in this respect. There was this one time when a traitor managed to ensure the slaughter of an entire village because no one picked up on the clues he left the villains. And there was another instant in which a certain wolf was too thick to pick up on some rather obvious choice-of-word clues, made a bad decision and was killed during the first Night. All in all, I try to catch these things as much as I can. Of course, this does not make me more or less guilty, just attempting to clarify something. Such early votes from Alcarillo all the time! Yes - Kath indeed voiced some worries concerning me, but I felt it could hardly be called an accusation. I also wish to add that even though Naria and malkatoj have excuses for being bandwagon persons, Nilp was still the safest vote yesterday and I would not be surprised if there is a wolf - perhaps 2, not excluding Nilp himself - among those who voted for him. But then again, a wolf likely voted for Gil as well and yesterday was an excellent opportunity for wolf on wolf voting (and strangely enough Farael / Eluchil jump to mind). Gurthang has said it earlier - Eluchil is acting a bit strange, accusing everyone who has accused him, but then again, newbies often do. I see Garin is a little less vocal today, Nilp is still talking in riddles and some people have yet to make an appearance. I think Menel is in the clear, with me, for now. I do not think he’d sacrifice such a valuable possible teammate as the Cobbler so easily.