Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island

[Kuruharan]

I'm not as worried of being suspected as I worry about starting a bandwagon against an innocent.

I don’t agree with this. You can’t be worried about how a vote seems. People are going to notice how votes look based upon the results. Unfortunately, beforehand there is no way to know which theories are right or wrong. The only way to find out is by testing. At the moment, we are all effectively operating blind. The only way to learn is to get a wolf and the only way to do that is experimentation. Once we do that we can start tying things together. If you start a bandwagon against an innocent, yeah, that’s going to be bad for you. However, there’s just no other way. You should always vote how you think and not worry about being wrong.

Now, what I think is that I’m still finding Garin suspicious, but today I’m more inclined to focus on Valier. My basis for this is her seemingly excessive agreeability combined with some subtle pointing toward Cailìn. However, this now brings up Cailìn’s status. Unfortunately, I’m unsure of how to proceed from here because this will involve getting rid of one of them, but how to choose. And then where to go if this whole trail goes cold?

And why hasn’t malkatoj been posting more? At the moment I’m inclined to believe in her innocence, but…