WWJ III - Nan Qualinmerë: Death Wish Valley - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

tar-ancalime · 01-23-2006, 07:29 AM

As Ms. ofRohan has rightly noted, Wayne, you did vote. What do you mean, you would have voted for Thin but ran out of time? Coulda, woulda, shoulda.

Since there seem to be several discussions going on regarding the voting record, I'll post it in its entirety as I understand it. (Someone please, please feel free to transcribe it into a nifty, easy-to-read format if you've got one!)

These are the votes from yesterday in order. The numbers indicate the running total of votes for that person, if more than one.

Anguirel-->Gandalf_the_white
Garin-->Anguirel
eonwe-->Valier
Mithalwen-->eonwe
Eomer-->Thinlomien
Fea-->Eomer
Shelob-->Eomer 2
Thinlomien-->Eomer 3
Valier-->Wayne
me-->Thinlomien 2
Abercrombie-->Garin
Kath-->eonwe
Fea--> RETRACTS Eomer 2
Fea-->Fea
Roa_Aoife-->Shelob
Valesse-->eonwe 3
Anguirel-->RETRACTS Gandalf
Anguirel-->Thinlomien 3
Wayne-->Fea 2
Gandalf_the_white no vote

Corrections? Amendments?

Now, the Harper's Index of the Day 1 voting:

Everyone voted but Gandalf.

Fea and Anguirel retracted.

Other than eonwe and Thinlomien, the following people received votes:

Eomer, Fea, Wayne, Garin, Shelob, Anguirel, Valier

That means that the following people didn't receive votes:

tar-ancalime, Valesse, Roa_Aoife, Kath, Ms. ofRohan, Mithalwen

Make of this what you will!

All I've got so far is that Wayne is being dishonest about his vote--if he wanted to vote for Thinlomien it wouldn't have taken any more time to do that than it did to vote for Fea (for all intents and purposes a throwaway vote so late in the day). By the time he got around to voting Thinlomien was already a dead wolf, so to speak, so another vote for her would have served only the purpose of saving eonwe. An innocent. The more I think about this Wayne situation the less comfortable I am with him. Care to explain yourself, Mr. Goblin?

01-23-2006, 07:29 AM	#11
tar-ancalime Shade of Carn Dûm Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: abaft the beam Posts: 303	give me the raw data, please! As Ms. ofRohan has rightly noted, Wayne, you did vote. What do you mean, you would have voted for Thin but ran out of time? Coulda, woulda, shoulda. Since there seem to be several discussions going on regarding the voting record, I'll post it in its entirety as I understand it. (Someone please, please feel free to transcribe it into a nifty, easy-to-read format if you've got one!) These are the votes from yesterday in order. The numbers indicate the running total of votes for that person, if more than one. Anguirel-->Gandalf_the_white Garin-->Anguirel eonwe-->Valier Mithalwen-->eonwe Eomer-->Thinlomien Fea-->Eomer Shelob-->Eomer 2 Thinlomien-->Eomer 3 Valier-->Wayne me-->Thinlomien 2 Abercrombie-->Garin Kath-->eonwe Fea--> RETRACTS Eomer 2 Fea-->Fea Roa_Aoife-->Shelob Valesse-->eonwe 3 Anguirel-->RETRACTS Gandalf Anguirel-->Thinlomien 3 Wayne-->Fea 2 Gandalf_the_white no vote Corrections? Amendments? Now, the Harper's Index of the Day 1 voting: Everyone voted but Gandalf. Fea and Anguirel retracted. Other than eonwe and Thinlomien, the following people received votes: Eomer, Fea, Wayne, Garin, Shelob, Anguirel, Valier That means that the following people didn't receive votes: tar-ancalime, Valesse, Roa_Aoife, Kath, Ms. ofRohan, Mithalwen Make of this what you will! All I've got so far is that Wayne is being dishonest about his vote--if he wanted to vote for Thinlomien it wouldn't have taken any more time to do that than it did to vote for Fea (for all intents and purposes a throwaway vote so late in the day). By the time he got around to voting Thinlomien was already a dead wolf, so to speak, so another vote for her would have served only the purpose of saving eonwe. An innocent. The more I think about this Wayne situation the less comfortable I am with him. Care to explain yourself, Mr. Goblin? __________________ Having fun wolfing it to the bitter end, I see, gaur-ancalime (lmp, ww13)