WWJ III - Nan Qualinmerë: Death Wish Valley

[Roa_Aoife]

Indeed it is Mith. And I agree- we need the full time. After reading back through tar's and Garin's posts, I am more suspicious of our carpenter than before.

On the first day, he started off with a fast vote for Ang, which drew a lot of attention. He was really unable to provide a reason for it, e xcept randomness, and refused to back down.

On the second day, he persisted in his vote for Ang, with no real reason at all, only to change quickly when it was seen that Shelob's fate was all but decided. He defended this vote by saying:

I should explain: in the world of retractable votes I want my vote to count, so if I must change it to seal someone's fate I will, just give me a good reason.

Having had the first vote for our hatmaker, how is he sealing anything?

Also, while he doggedly held to his change of mind, he continued to spread suspicion and accusations. He did very little acknowledgement of Shelob after that. If he really believed her to be a wolf, why not continue in that line? Why the darting around?

Garin?

EDIT: Thanks, Mith, for the vote of confidence. I provided a rather (in my opinion) solid defence of myself yesterday with my first post, after Ang had voted for me.