Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVII: The Saga Continues to Continue quite Continuously

[the guy who be short]

Originally Posted by SpM

Yet your case against morm today seems to have transformed into something of a single-minded persecution of him, and it unnerves me.

Apologies if it unnerves you, but I am certain that we have a wolf here. And whilst it is very definitely a persecution, I won't deny that, it is not singleminded. I wanted to vote for morm at the offset, but instead decided to analyse Naria, Marco and Gil before casting a vote. I have finished with the first two and in both cases found reason for suspicion. Gil I shall do as soon as I finish this reply. Indeed, a review was entirely necessary, considering that my secondary suspect beforehand had been Glirdan, and by the end of tomorrow, if I live, I intend to have covered as much of the village as possible.

That said, while I do suspect Naria, Marco and Formen, the focus of my day remains morm.

I felt much the same way as mormegil yesterday about Cailin. That is why I voted for her, although I am not sure that I expressed my reasons with any more precision than morm did. I reached that view entirely independently, before I had seen what mormegil had to say about her

A brave thing to admit to. I will confess, I saw your post claiming that you had reached your own conclusions about Cailin a few days ago, but dismissed it. I presumed that mormegil had influenced you, even if you yourself had not noticed this.

As to how that affects my beliefs... well, put simply, I saw no reason to suspect Cailin, and it surprises me that you, SpM, did. I don't think you are a wolf - much the opposite infact - but that seems odd. Perhaps I simply missed something with regards to her. But I still think morm is guilty.

I have a feeling that he is innocent.

How strong is that feeling?