Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVIII: The Play’s The Thing…

[Formendacil]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

So here's my thoughts on all my fellow villagers...

I guess I'm either honoured to come in for no suspicions or insulted for not being a fellow villager... That's twice I've been left off of major lists in this game so far. Thank you Boromir, thank you Spawn. If I was a wolf trying to hide, you'd undoubtedly be my two accomplices...

Now, by and large I've got no major disputations to make about your list, Boromir, but I'd like to make a comment or two regarding:

Garin: Fits perfectly the description of the flip-flopper I remarked about above. But the tough decision about this is...is Garin an innocent that bases his decision off of what we say? Or is he a bandwagoning wolf to get someone innocent lynched?

If you ask me, Garin leans more towards your first option than your second. As noted elsewhere, I'm a player who tends to judge people by how closely they play to form, and described as such, Garin is playing perfectly to form. He is, from what I've watched, very much a flip-flopper, especially early in the game. He is also, and I crave your indulgence Garin for saying so, rather overly-eager to ingratiate himself with the village.

That said, however, I'm not willing to say that he's not a Werewolf yet, since both of the two games he's played that I was also a part of, he turned out to be a Werewolf in the end...