Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVIII: The Play’s The Thing…

[Celuien]

Originally Posted by The Saucepan Man

No, that’s wrong. If we are correct today, tomorrow starts at Wolves 1, villagers 4. And, if we are then wrong tomorrow, we end the Day at villagers 3, Wolves 1, with a further Day for the last two innocent villagers to find the remaining Wolf.

Okay. My mistake. *pulls out kindergarten learn to count book*

Honestly, I'm somewhat uneasy about voting Aiwendil today since Farael does look far more suspicious to me. If Farael is a wolf, he has been playing a fairly bold game all along, and the Kath ranking comment would be consistent with his strategy as a wolf.

I see your point about Aiwendil, however, being in a very, very good position to cover any wolvish tracks. And if I force myself to put aside my being taken in my Eomer, he doesn't look good in light of his voting record there. Aiwendil's consistent caution would be what I would expect of a wolf, somewhat more than Farael's boldness. At the same time, Eomer was a very bold wolf, and I suppose they could both have been playing a bold game, thinking that we wouldn't suspect a double team of bold wolves.

So thinking about it, I suppose Farael and Aiwendil objectively look about equally wolvish to me. Subjectively, I'm leaning toward Farael.