Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVIII: The Play’s The Thing…

[Aiwendil]

Well done, my dear Saucepan Wolf! I was afraid that by the last DAY, you'd stick out like a sore thumb, still being alive and all. But apparently the two wolf sacrifices did the trick.

It really was peculiar, though, how un-suspected SPM was throughout the game. If I'm not mistaken, the heaviest attacks against him came from me.

Mormegil wrote:

How did you guess Holby was the seer? Don't tell me it was dumb luck!

Afraid it was. Actually, after DAY 1 we rather suspected that either Tar or Farael was the Seer, given Tar's "random" vote for Eomer and Farael's vicious attack against me. We seriously considered killing one of them that NIGHT, but then we thought that this would draw too much attention to either me or Eomer. Holbytlass was chosen largely because no one was suspicious of her so far and her death left no obvious trail.

Mormegil and Boromir, on the other hand, we had pegged. I believe we started to suspect that one or both of you might be Gifted on the NIGHT we killed Spawn. By the following NIGHT, we were sure that Boromir was the Ranger and Mormegil the Hunter.

I hunted Aiwendil the 2nd to last night and came very close to changing my vote

We almost killed you one NIGHT earlier but we went for Boromir instead because we feared he might be protecting you (actually, I believe we had some fairly far-fetched idea that you might be setting us up in some way). And Saucepan and I hesitated a great deal before deciding to kill you when we did - for fear you'd be hunting me. What made up my mind in the end was the fact that most likely you were only going to get more and more suspicious of me on subsequent NIGHTs, so if we didn't kill you then, we might not have another chance.