Survivor: The Second Age

[JennyHallu]

Agh! The Phantom isn't impressed with me! What shall I do?

What shall I do? I shall go straight back to voting for people on the basis of their names.

++the phantom

We're all dead, what makes him THE phantom? Isn't he just A phantom?

And...

--Elrond, ++Orophir, because 'e's 'orrible. Sorry, Ang, I will not be able to take the anti-monkey platform today, as A phantom has pointed out that monkeys don't exist.

[The Saucepan Man]

Hello TP (or is it AP), how nice to see you here. Charming as ever, I see.

Originally Posted by the phantom

Seven of his ten votes this game have been for elves, and the three that weren't for elves were for Numenorian Kings with elf-blood running through their veins.

Hmm, I wonder how that could be. Perhaps because a third of the original contestants were Elves and most of the rest were Numenorean Kings ...

[the phantom]

what makes him THE phantom? Isn't he just A phantom?

If you haven't noticed, I am intelligent and have a good sense of humor. You see, I am the model of a phantom, the phantom by which all other phantoms are judged. Sort of like all basketball stars are compared to the great Michael Jordan.

By changing your vote to Oropher, Jenny, you have increased your phantomicity. Keep up the good work.

Originally Posted by Sauce

Charming as ever, I see.

Yes, yes, I'm always so kind and subtle when arguing, aren't I?

You might find me more agreeable if all the participants on this thread were more logical.

Perhaps because a third of the original contestants were Elves

So, because 33% were elves, you voted for them 70% of the time?

and most of the rest were Numenorean Kings

And, because most of the rest were Numenorean Kings, you voted for them every time you weren't voting for an elf?

I'm sorry, Sauce, but I won't be fully convinced that you aren't anti-elf until I see you vote for one of the Other Speakers, or a man without elf blood.