are there she orcs??

[Eonwe]

So he eliminated the female element.

How? You can't just make up some other reproduction sceme. Not to mention Melkor couldn't create anything on his own...

Arnt orcs just spawned of alchemy from 'black pits?

I fear that here PJ is just as far off as Valinor is for a Mortal man. Is there anywhere I'm missing? Where did this 'spawning orc' theory come from. Granted, I'm just as weirded out by orc reproduction as the next guy, but I think 'spawning orcs' is just a by-product of other fantacy influence that go in more for the 'revolting evil creatures' model. But I've been wrong before.

Finally, I don't see much to elaborate on. Glorfindel, I understand, is the product of rethinking over a long period of time. Rethinking of the whole nature of Elves. I don't see how you can really screw up "son of".