WWJ Attack of the Werecats:The ppuuuurrfect village

[Diamond18]

I think Kath's plan is a good one. As a Cat I'm not sure how much this plan would benefit her, since she definitely wouldn't be getting the Seeker toNight, even if she managed to get the Protector. However since I'm not the Seeker, obviously, it's out of my hands.

One thing though -- why the need to lynch me? If you know I'm the Taker, you know I'm innocent, ergo killing me depletes you of one innocent and if I'm wrong about who I Take, that's two innocents. It would be better to just lynch whoever I would have decided to Take if I were to be lynched.

Unfortunately, this may be the last chance I get to make any contribution toDay, as I probably won't be around for the deadline. Please do not lynch me for any strategic reason, even if you know who the Seeker is toDay, because I will probably not be able to notify Valier of who I want to Take. The person whose name she has now may be innocent, may even be the Seeker. I most likely won't be able to change my Taken till toNight.

I would suggest that if this plan is followed, you leave me be. If the Seeker is revealed, the Protector can protect him/her toNight. If the Cat is smart, he/she will go after the Protector, and forget about even trying for the Seeker because we'll all know who's being protected. If the Cat guesses wrongly about who the Protector is, so much the better for all of us.

[Kath]

No I see your point Diamond, there would not be much point in lynching you other than to deplete the number of unknowns but that would also decrease the number of knowns.

morm I was thinking. Say the Protector and the Cat chose the same person and they happened to be the Seer. In that case, the Seer doesn't reveal themselves toDay and the Protector chooses Diamond to protect since they know she is not the Seer. Then the Seer can reveal themselves tomorrow and the Protector can protect them two Nights in a row.

The flaw there is that the Cat might get the Protector toNight in which case this entire idea is shot to pieces.

[mormegil]

Kath the problem with this whole discussion is that

1. It's far too speculative and either the Seeker isn't coming forward or is one that hasn't been around today

2. Has taken us away from the primary focus of searching for cats and you did it just at a time when I began to question you.

[Kath]

morm I simply wanted to know what people thought of the idea. I certainly wasn't trying to take attention away from finding the Cat because whatever the response to my idea we still have to try and lynch the Cat toDay. The plan was speculative and no it doesn't look like the Seeker is going to take it up, but it was worth putting the idea out there so that in future Days it can perhaps be taken up.

Also, you seem to be implying I thought it up to avoid suspicion from you. Ok, you want answers from me I'll give them, but you have to ask some. The only thing I feel I really needed to reply to was my pushing for the double death last Night because it was very out of character for me, but you specifically told me not to bother explaining that so I didn't. If you now want an explanation from me I'm happy to give it.

YesterDay Telp was going to die whatever the case. Her death would have told us nothing unless she was the final Cat. We had two people left on Nogrod's list that, though Valier had said was purely random, had already caught us two Cats. Whether random or not the track record was enough to make it worth finding out the identity of Lommy as well. Also, it is very likely that we would have spent toDay wondering about Lommy because she was on that list and I thought it would be better to rid ourselves of that confusion since we had the chance, so we could concentrate better toDay. Yes it was out of character as I normally despise double lynches, but on this rare occasion I thought it might actually benefit us a little.

[Roa_Aoife]

namely my theory that all cats were defenders of the "random vote"..... and hey, two of the cats so far WERE.

But there were more people defending the random vote than Eonwe and the two known werecats. I understand a busy schedule, I have one too. But you should still try to post something of value or else not post at all.

On the seeker plan - I've seen it work really well before, (I was the seer at the time), but right now, I think the seeker should only reveal themselves if they find a cat or if they are about to be lynched.

I beg you to dream of Kath tonight as it will either confirm my suspicion or make her a known innocent.

If we're making requests, I'd like to know about Morm myself. He's been making me uneasy this whole game. I was working on an analysis toDay, but I'm on a friend's computer right now and can't access it.

[Formendacil]

Well, I have to vote before the deadline, and the way things stand it's

Kath- 1 votes,
Formendacil- 2 votes,
Glirdan- 2 votes.


Quite frankly, I really don't want to go to the block today- although the idea does have its merits.

The reason is that I am Innocent. In fact, I am a bona fide "Proven Innocent".

You see, I was the Birthday Dreamer last night...

If anyone else in this village dares make that claim, then by all means: lynch me- but lynch them as well.

In the meantime, Glirdan looks rather suspicious simply for that reason: here I have been playing weirdly, and he comes out and defends me... Inside information?

I'm not entirely convinced of that, but to save my own hide...

++ Glirdan

[Roa_Aoife]

Form, if you're going to come out as the Birthday dreamer, at least tell us who who dreamed of so we know they too are innocent.

However, how do we know you didn't dream of the last cat last night and thus become another threat?

[mormegil]

Originally Posted by Formendacil

The reason is that I am Innocent. In fact, I am a bona fide "Proven Innocent".

You see, I was the Birthday Dreamer last night...

Well between Form and Diamond I think my suspicion list has narrowed substantially.

Who did you dream of? That might add an innocent to the list.