Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXI: Dueling Wizards Werewolf

[Celuien]

Originally Posted by Kath

Post 137:
Suspects Nogrod, phantom and dad (who is dad?). If she's an original wolf as someone suggested I'm not sure she would go after Nogrod quite so strongly. A good bluff to be sure, but still. Though at this time she wouldn't have known it would start such a bandwagon so it could have been a relatively safe option. Also suspects Sauce (unless he is her dad, I'm so confused!) as his posts aren't as insightful as normal. We know Sauce was innocent so anyone she has said this about may be likely to be innocent as well. Says she doesn't suspect Loki.

Naria's dad was Saucy.

Naria might still have been an original wolf. The wolves don't have to know each other's identities, so even if Naria and Nogrod were both wolves that first day, she could have accused him accidentally.

Couldn't find anyone who defended both of them. Of course, Naria did say so little that she never really came under enough suspicion to warrant a defense.

About the phantom:

Phantom's death last night I think makes it even less likely that Nilp is a wolf (or EW). Phantom advertised to become the Hunter yesterday and voted for Nilp. Had Nilp been a wolf, knowing that tp was a good candidate to become the Hunter, I doubt the wolves would have chosen him for a kill. Or have been allowed to choose him, as the Hunter's failure would have revealed the EW to the village.

Finally, Roa definitely seems innocent to me after what happened with Nogrod yesterday. I seriously doubt a wolf-Roa would have attacked him so strongly yesterday.

EDIT: crossed with 365 on.