Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXI: Dueling Wizards Werewolf - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Caranlondien · 05-18-2006, 04:28 PM

Alas, how I have rued my vote from yesterDay... But, as Firefoot said, you win some, you lose some.

I agree with Gurthang; I think the time has come for the GW to reveal him/herself. Unless they have some amazing, revolutionary plot up their sleeve, it looks like we innocents could only benefit from knowing the GW's identity.

Having, overNight, reviewed Valier's posts from yesterDay, I found myself suspecting her strongly. Her first post toDay has just confused me. How are you so certain Roa is the EW, Valier? And why do you think she would kill you, if she were?

I know this is the blasted "polling the village" and I'll be jumped upon for it, but does anyone have something in their lorebooks about Roa as an innocent? I'd like to know if she's behaving as she does when she's innocent, because, to me, her behavior so far is reminiscent of her days as a werewolf.

Diamond seemed odd to me yesterDay, but that was just intuition, and I realize I may be wrong. Her first post toDay seems normal, anyway.

I still don't know about Eomer, though for now I'm inclined to trust him, as I've other more pressing suspects.

Diamond18 · 05-18-2006, 04:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Caranlondien

I still don't know about Eomer, though for now I'm inclined to trust him, as I've other more pressing suspects.

I don't trust ANYONE anymore. We have two new wolves overnight, blargh. Sorry for the pessimistic tone, I'm just not having much success looking over yesterDay's posts, and the knowledge that people who were innocent then are guilty now is really bugging me.

Valier · 05-18-2006, 04:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Caran

Having, overNight, reviewed Valier's posts from yesterDay, I found myself suspecting her strongly. Her first post toDay has just confused me. How are you so certain Roa is the EW, Valier? And why do you think she would kill you, if she were?

I know I sounded odd yesterday, but I was up all night(RL) and the connection of Roa being the EW and the wolves we have found sounded almost too good to be true...But I have thoroughly convinced myself that it is in fact Roa who is the EW. Now me voting for her today might be useless because the EW now knows who the GW is and it's only a matter of time before she (Roa) is reveiled to be the EW.And if she is the EW she can not be lynched anyways... So I would like to find a wolf today and let the wizards do their own thing when they are ready...I do think the UnSeer should come forward and tell us who they dreamt of so we can narrow our list of innocents...hoping none of them have been changed to the dark side.

05-18-2006, 04:28 PM	#1
Caranlondien Shade of Carn Dûm Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Bag-Endless-Fuel Posts: 339	Alas, how I have rued my vote from yesterDay... But, as Firefoot said, you win some, you lose some. I agree with Gurthang; I think the time has come for the GW to reveal him/herself. Unless they have some amazing, revolutionary plot up their sleeve, it looks like we innocents could only benefit from knowing the GW's identity. Having, overNight, reviewed Valier's posts from yesterDay, I found myself suspecting her strongly. Her first post toDay has just confused me. How are you so certain Roa is the EW, Valier? And why do you think she would kill you, if she were? I know this is the blasted "polling the village" and I'll be jumped upon for it, but does anyone have something in their lorebooks about Roa as an innocent? I'd like to know if she's behaving as she does when she's innocent, because, to me, her behavior so far is reminiscent of her days as a werewolf. Diamond seemed odd to me yesterDay, but that was just intuition, and I realize I may be wrong. Her first post toDay seems normal, anyway. I still don't know about Eomer, though for now I'm inclined to trust him, as I've other more pressing suspects.