Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXII: Hic Monstrae Trucidant - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

the guy who be short · 05-31-2006, 04:56 PM

Formendacil posted thrice yesterday.

Post 7 - Says nothing of importance.

Post 29 - Repeat performance, haha.

Post 103 - Form votes Caranlondien for being careful in covering her tracks.

Firstly, I would like to apologise for the haphazard chronology of the following. I first searched for all posts containing the word Formendacil, forgetting that some would refer to him as Form. I then had to go through again searching for Form. And it's far too late for me to edit for something so minor as that.

LMP votes Form. He says Form is always a wolf when he plays, thats the way it is.
Sauce then votes for Form, changing from Fea, for saying little of importance.

Spawn says Form seems more frustrated about Day 1s than usual.
Cailin says Form may be a wolf, but she doesn't know or see anything odd about him. Mith says she may vote for him if he keeps whinging. Cailin then says she thinks Form is being odd by being more silent and sullen than usual. Cailin changes her vote to Form from Lhuna.

SpM rants about how Form is wrong in thinking Day 1s are useless. Naturally.

****

Now that you have all the bare information, here are my thoughts.

Formendacil may have been killed for giving us no information whatsoever. I think this is most likely. We are confusing ourselves to death - quite literally - and the removal of a quiet villager allows us to continue in this vein.

However, he could also have been killed for a multitude of other reasons. Perhaps to incriminate an innocent, Caranlondien. Perhaps they thought he was the Seer and Caranlondien is a wolf. This is less likely as he did not mention her until his last post.

He could also have been killed to cast suspicion on those who voted for him - Sauce and LMP and Cailin - or, using reverse psychology, as a bluff to make them less suspicious. However, the latter is unlikely as they were not under much suspicion in the first place, excluding SpM. For him, this theory is credible.

In conclusion, I think he was likely killed because we were all barking up the wrong tree, and the wolves want to keep it that way. So we need some new people to accuse.

****

One thing I noticed was very interesting. Cailin says that she thought Form was acting normally. Later spawn, in a very long post, casually remarked that she thought Form was being more defensive than usual. Later still, Cailin echoes this and switches her vote to Form. I find this very suspicious and wouldn't put it past both of them being wolves. I would like to hear why Cailin suddenly changed her mind. Spawn, meanwhile, appears to be very influential in her summary posts.

Thoughts on Boromir after I come back in about 12 hours, hopefully. In short, I thought he was a loud, mistaken innocent. Bed now.

05-31-2006, 04:56 PM	#11
the guy who be short Shadowed Prince Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Thulcandra Posts: 2,343	Formendacil the Dead Formendacil posted thrice yesterday. Post 7 - Says nothing of importance. Post 29 - Repeat performance, haha. Post 103 - Form votes Caranlondien for being careful in covering her tracks. Firstly, I would like to apologise for the haphazard chronology of the following. I first searched for all posts containing the word Formendacil, forgetting that some would refer to him as Form. I then had to go through again searching for Form. And it's far too late for me to edit for something so minor as that. LMP votes Form. He says Form is always a wolf when he plays, thats the way it is. Sauce then votes for Form, changing from Fea, for saying little of importance. Spawn says Form seems more frustrated about Day 1s than usual. Cailin says Form may be a wolf, but she doesn't know or see anything odd about him. Mith says she may vote for him if he keeps whinging. Cailin then says she thinks Form is being odd by being more silent and sullen than usual. Cailin changes her vote to Form from Lhuna. SpM rants about how Form is wrong in thinking Day 1s are useless. Naturally. ** Now that you have all the bare information, here are my thoughts. Formendacil may have been killed for giving us no information whatsoever. I think this is most likely. We are confusing ourselves to death - quite literally - and the removal of a quiet villager allows us to continue in this vein. However, he could also have been killed for a multitude of other reasons. Perhaps to incriminate an innocent, Caranlondien. Perhaps they thought he was the Seer and Caranlondien is a wolf. This is less likely as he did not mention her until his last post. He could also have been killed to cast suspicion on those who voted for him - Sauce and LMP and Cailin - or, using reverse psychology, as a bluff to make them less suspicious. However, the latter is unlikely as they were not under much suspicion in the first place, excluding SpM. For him, this theory is credible. In conclusion, I think he was likely killed because we were all barking up the wrong tree, and the wolves want to keep it that way. So we need some new people to accuse. One thing I noticed was very interesting. Cailin says that she thought Form was acting normally. Later spawn, in a very long post, casually remarked that she thought Form was being more defensive than usual. Later still, Cailin echoes this and switches her vote to Form. I find this very suspicious and wouldn't put it past both of them being wolves. I would like to hear why Cailin suddenly changed her mind. Spawn**, meanwhile, appears to be very influential in her summary posts. Thoughts on Boromir after I come back in about 12 hours, hopefully. In short, I thought he was a loud, mistaken innocent. Bed now.