Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXII: Hic Monstrae Trucidant

[the guy who be short]

According to Mr SPaM (Hey, other people are saying it too...), Tom, Lommy, Spawn and Fin voted for Boro. Yay. A relatively small number of people to analyse.

Tom - At the time of Tom's vote, it seemed unlikely that Boro would be killed. 8 Other people had garnered one vote each. It is entirely possible that he was a wolf casting a safe vote.

Thus far, Tom has posted fice (five times).

Post 43 - He votes boro, but says "There is no real evidence against boromir." Why not vote for one of the eight others then?

And that was his only post on Day 1! Hmm.

Day 2 He makes more sense though. He makes sound points about Form's death, but largely echoes others. (Post 124). Then he vaguely accuses morm and Caran in post 146. Post 149 centres on SpM and doesn't make much sense to me - spM may be influential, but he doesn't control the village. Post 151 states the LMP and morm should explain votes, something I agree with.

Conclusion: Neutral. He makes a little sense, but I don't know what to think.

Seriously, though... TGWBS is currently my biggest interest.

What is it with girls in this village stalking me? First Kath, with her blunt admittal of "wanting me" just before she got killed, now you. And I'm not even making a pokemon use attract. You should know you can't have me...

[the guy who be short]

Originally Posted by spawn

TGWBS has posted a lot, but a big part of it is strategical talk such as why Form was killed. He mentiones some names as supicious, but doesn't really accuse anyone or make cases. At the beginning of the Day he said that Caran looked bad, but then he ignores her whereas a moment later when he had said that he'd ignore morm, TGWBS wonders his behaviour. Well, opinions do change, but he suspected Cailín for that earlier toDay...

I'm wary of people who mostly mentions some names without really stating what they think of them or analysing them, but to be fair, TGWBS promised an analysis of his list in #156, so I look forward to that. In the meantime I remain slightly suspicious of him.

I'm making "cases" at the moment, though they end up neutral often. You see, I'm rather unwilling to jump on minor details and accuse somebody of wolvery. It often ends in innocent people being hanged.

I said Caran was easily swayed by others and this was bad. This was hardly a detailed case against her and the discussion turned to more interesting matters.

I did not say I'd ignore morm, or, if I did, I didn't mean it. I meant that I would delay forming a case against him - as others have done - to allow my own ideas to develop. I have not formed a case against him, I have merely asked him to explain his perpetual distrust of me.

I suspected Cailin of being in league with you. She then responded adequately for me to change her mind. But I still think you influenced her.

[the guy who be short]

Second person to vote for Boro. Again, little chance of Boro being lynched at this point - SpM had three votes, Form and I two each.

However, as SpM said, Lommy seemed far too violent in her attacks on Boro. There would be no need for a wolf to be so loud or aggressive on Day 1. So, unless she's a stupid wolf, I don't see that happening.

Spawn should have been wily enough not to fall for attacking Boro, as SpM remarks. However...she put Boro in the lead, something I don't think a wolf would willingly do. But I definitely wouldn't put it past wolf-spawn.

Fin... I don't know. I don't know if she's daring enough to vote for Boro last as a wolf. I suspect not.

So I suspect spawn a little.

Now I have put my own thoughts down, I can turn to analysing mormegil, Caran and durelin, whom I am most interested in at the moment.