Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXII: Hic Monstrae Trucidant - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Nogrod · 06-05-2006, 08:08 AM

Of lists...

I still think that letting Caran make the list all by herself would not have been the wisest thing to do. It would have been like putting all our eggs into the same basket. And even Caran admits this. She has also openly confessed being easily swayed by other peoples arguments (and Morm already pointed out the other side of the problem).

But if we can assume now, that we know of, or possibly should at least trust for three innocents (Caran, tgwbs, Durelin), it might be wise to see their collective lists. Everyone of the three picking f.ex. four suspicious people and then we could pick the common choices as our list of sorts. That would greatly enhance the "objectiviness" of the list.

Of Fea-lynch...

What happened? From my point of view I was first as worried as you seem still to be and tried to call for a stop to that seeming madness. Then I had some time to reconsider and started thinking that it was the Changeling-Fea that had picked the Seer (or the Ranger) last night and was afraid to pick a wolf soon and so being forced to kill the Gifted. If we add to this that she seemed to have RL-problems and was willing to get off the game, lynching would be the right way to go - preventing any actively-playing innocent (or even someone she had picked already and knew to be innocent) to be lynched. It surely was, and probably is still more probable that we lynch innocents, not the wolves. So wise in that sense.

But as I said, I would like to see lists by Caran, tgwbs and Durelin. I might be ready to vote on the basis of those toDay.

06-05-2006, 08:08 AM	#11
Nogrod Flame of the Ainulindalë Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Wearing rat's coat, crowskin, crossed staves in a field behaving as the wind behaves Posts: 9,308	Of lists... I still think that letting Caran make the list all by herself would not have been the wisest thing to do. It would have been like putting all our eggs into the same basket. And even Caran admits this. She has also openly confessed being easily swayed by other peoples arguments (and Morm already pointed out the other side of the problem). But if we can assume now, that we know of, or possibly should at least trust for three innocents (Caran, tgwbs, Durelin), it might be wise to see their collective lists. Everyone of the three picking f.ex. four suspicious people and then we could pick the common choices as our list of sorts. That would greatly enhance the "objectiviness" of the list. Of Fea-lynch... What happened? From my point of view I was first as worried as you seem still to be and tried to call for a stop to that seeming madness. Then I had some time to reconsider and started thinking that it was the Changeling-Fea that had picked the Seer (or the Ranger) last night and was afraid to pick a wolf soon and so being forced to kill the Gifted. If we add to this that she seemed to have RL-problems and was willing to get off the game, lynching would be the right way to go - preventing any actively-playing innocent (or even someone she had picked already and knew to be innocent) to be lynched. It surely was, and probably is still more probable that we lynch innocents, not the wolves. So wise in that sense. But as I said, I would like to see lists by Caran, tgwbs and Durelin. I might be ready to vote on the basis of those toDay. __________________ Upon the hearth the fire is red Beneath the roof there is a bed; But not yet weary are our feet...