WWJ IX: Psychotic Penguins: The Crossing of Helcaraxë - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Roa_Aoife · 06-08-2006, 02:15 PM

Boromir analysis (because he's seemed off to me since his second post)

1st post

Nonsense (ie in character posting), says the biggest set back of the cobbler is the confusion that could be caused, agrees that getting rid of the cobbler is benefitial to the village

2nd post

Says Valier and Eonwe are acting too wierd to be penguins, thinks Firefoot is logical, doesn't see anything of significance in Roa's, phantom's or Diamond's posts.

3rd post

Says the only person he would expect to double bluff is phantom, or possibly ang,lists all the villagers minus himself:

Valier- too eccentric to be guilty
Diamond- also too eccentric, but he finds her quote about the seer and cobbler odd

Doesn't know about Naria

Mac- thinks mac is innocent, and behaving like a newbie
Lal- doesn't mind summaries, but doesn't really see a point
Firefoot- if innocent, good, if not, bad
Jenny- trying to squelch conversation
Roa- goes off about theories being a good thing
phantom- more likely to be a penguin than Mac, acting normally
spawn- seems fishy
Ang- nothing strange
Eonwe- having day 1 fun

Disagrees with phantom's plan

4th post

doesn't like to read the rules, remark about typos, answers Firefoots remark about analysis,responds to Jenny with apologies, thinks it's a good idea to lay down ideas for the gifted to follow

List of blieved innocents:

Spawn- for input about Ang
Jenny-
Eonwe
Valier
Macalaure

List of iffys

phantom- phantom plays the same when guilty or innocent
Firefoot- more observant than anything else
Naria- nothing really posted
Encaitare- nothing posted
Diamond- too confusing

List of suspected

Roa- doesn't like her supposed dis of theories
Lalaith- thinks lal is trying to nudge suspicion towards other people
Anguirel- spawn's comments
Kitanna- cobbler

5th post

Note on having cross posted

analysis to follow

06-08-2006, 02:15 PM	#11
Roa_Aoife Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Someday, I'll rule all of it. Posts: 1,696	Boromir analysis (because he's seemed off to me since his second post) 1st post Nonsense (ie in character posting), says the biggest set back of the cobbler is the confusion that could be caused, agrees that getting rid of the cobbler is benefitial to the village 2nd post Says Valier and Eonwe are acting too wierd to be penguins, thinks Firefoot is logical, doesn't see anything of significance in Roa's, phantom's or Diamond's posts. 3rd post Says the only person he would expect to double bluff is phantom, or possibly ang,lists all the villagers minus himself: Valier- too eccentric to be guilty Diamond- also too eccentric, but he finds her quote about the seer and cobbler odd Doesn't know about Naria Mac- thinks mac is innocent, and behaving like a newbie Lal- doesn't mind summaries, but doesn't really see a point Firefoot- if innocent, good, if not, bad Jenny- trying to squelch conversation Roa- goes off about theories being a good thing phantom- more likely to be a penguin than Mac, acting normally spawn- seems fishy Ang- nothing strange Eonwe- having day 1 fun Disagrees with phantom's plan 4th post doesn't like to read the rules, remark about typos, answers Firefoots remark about analysis,responds to Jenny with apologies, thinks it's a good idea to lay down ideas for the gifted to follow List of blieved innocents: Spawn- for input about Ang Jenny- Eonwe Valier Macalaure List of iffys phantom- phantom plays the same when guilty or innocent Firefoot- more observant than anything else Naria- nothing really posted Encaitare- nothing posted Diamond- too confusing List of suspected Roa- doesn't like her supposed dis of theories Lalaith- thinks lal is trying to nudge suspicion towards other people Anguirel- spawn's comments Kitanna- cobbler 5th post Note on having cross posted analysis to follow __________________ We can't all be Roas* when it comes to analysing...* -Lommy I didn't say you're evil, Roa, I said you're exasperating. -Nerwen