What was the WORST new scene in the three EE's?

[Kath]

Not that this topic has generated much discussion yet, but in the event that it does, please stay away from excessive G/W-K bashing.

The fanfic or the scene

Worst new scene, agreed the end of the Mouth of Sauron bit, though only because of what we know from the books, with Aragorn not even needing to raise a weapon to cause fear.