WW XXIIX - Queer Lodgings

[Durelin]

Originally Posted by Rune

The killing Menel was a comment of Ang saying that he thought one of us to be a wolf, but only one. I was merely saying "if it is so then Menel is the wolf, because I am innocent"

I know that was your response to Ang, but I want to know what you think of Menel.

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

Well, Menel is very interesting for me too look at as he reminds me of. . . me. One would think it would make it easy for me to spot of he was innocent or not, but it is not so as wolf-me and innocent-me is not all that different.

Anyways at first Menel came off as very innocent looking, voicing some of the same semi-vauge thoughts I was thinking. This is the main reason I have not yet thought of him as a wolf, but I have had a hard time relating to what he has said of late.

wow! I just realised something while reading over Menels latest posts. He is very vauge about everybody exept me, the rest of you he pretty much says "this person could be a wolf" and then he halfway withdraw the statement. really this is a very good tactic for a wolf. In case he is lynched there will be as good as no trace to his fellow wolves. His only suspect is me (innocent) and the rest of you he says pretty much the same thing about.

Now I hope that Durelin is not a very cunning wolf, that by asking simple question can lead people in sertain directions.

[Durelin]

Good point about Menel's "suspicion record" leaving no trace, Rune. (That's why I ask questions, to get good observations like that.) And if he is a Wolf, he has no reason to focus his supposed suspicion, particularly at this point. So far we innocents have done well lynching each other.

Let's look at Valier...

ToDay (Day 4), she's posted only once, but though apparently she had time to list what the Seer should do, she did not have time to suggest what the rest of us should do; as in, who we should lynch.

Day 1 - Not there at all. Was sick. Posts once to say so and apologize. Okay.

Day 2 - Posts three times. Once to apologize for not being there and voting, another to say that she thought Volo was innocent for the same reasons that Menel thought he was, and thinks Menel is innocent because he thought that (everyone was looking at Eomer voters). Then posts again to say that Lommy gets freaked out when she has a special role and that she has a weird feeling about her. Votes Lommy.

Day 3 - Posts three times. Lists everyone left alive, then categorizes them based on suspicion.

Originally Posted by Val

Ok now people I am unsure of are....
Menel
Kath
Durelin
Nilp

People I have suspicion of
Nogrod
Rune
Ang

Innocent?
Volo
Holby
Boro
Lommy

Basically says that Nogrod seems most guilty to her because he is suspicious of people she thinks are innocent. Says that he seems like a Wolf who is trying to get the ordos to kill each other. (Because Wolves might do other things?) Rune and Ang she just has a "feeling" about.

Then posts to agree with Ang about Nogrod. Then she says that she missed Volo's post and realizes now why he is found suspicious (basically because of a connection with Nogrod). But then oddly enough she suggest that he might be hinting at being gifted. Eh? Wot wot? Why isn't he dead yet, killed by the Wolves?

Then posts to say that she's pretty sure two of the wolves are Kath and Rune. At least she's consistent with Rune...but what happened to Nogrod? Oh, yeah, that's right...I voted for Kath right before her. Convenient vote. She also questions Nilp's "scraping by with a post a day" when she herself posts only minimally.

So...she seems to have a routine. Posts once or twice before the voting really starts...then comes back after a while, votes, and leaves. But she is far from consistent in her suspicion. Her way of "suspecting" is much like Menel's.

I hope Holby and Lommy will be able to post soon. Argh, this silence is unnerving. Maybe, Seer, if you have anything at all, it's time to come out. Because we seem not to be getting very far.