Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls

[Gil-Galad]

I must be inclined to look at those who showed sympathy or acceptance with TGWBS, mainly because it is not wise for faithfuls to sacrifice one of there own, too much risk in it because of one goes then there a chacne of losing another and going downhill.

this late in the game it is not wise to sacrifce their own faithfuls because the list is dwindling and the faithfuls will have greater chances of being lynched out, i would have to agree with SPM's list, but here is my suspicous

Durelin
Hookbill
SPM

SPm wil lalways be on my suspicous, though he is starting to lean off of it... but i hate being fooled by big words...

[Lalaith]

Very quick one, as I won't be back til much later in the day...

Villagers, if I'm right about who the wolves are, we really are in trouble.
These Faithfuls are also among the most frequent and vocal posters - most of the innocents are quiet ones. I have a horrible feeling of deja vu, vis a vis duelling wizards and the wolf of the Rohirrim. Beware. Please post and participate, innocents.

[Thinlómien]

I'm here and I'm talking and the first think I've got to say is that I absolutely love yesterDay's narration!

~*~

SPM has to be a faithful. I think we'd better re-lynch him. I don't have the time right now to make a well-constructed case against him, but there are some points I wish to bring up.

Anyone else than a faithful would not say this:

Originally Posted by Sauce

I am certain that either Lalaith or Lommy is a Faithful and, since they have both been defending each other every so often, I wonder whether they both might be.

Any innocent person would seriously reconsider before posting this or the other similar remarks SPM has made about me and Lalaith. An innocent wouldn't maybe find that suspicious, or dare to point that out. Because there are still two gifteds in the game and it's a fact that they know each others' identity. An ordo would be careful to accuse any two people with a seeming "bond" between them. A gifted would be more careful too: he could guess that such attack might reveal his role, and I don't think SPM would be that careless as a gifted. I wouldn't post this if I thought there was any real considerable possibility of SPM anything else than a deceitful elf-lover. (If we lynch him or and he turns out to be one of the remaining gifteds - which I very much doubt - I think you can strangle me for revealing him, and I deserve it. )

The whole game SPM has been making things look more sinister than they are and twisting words. Remember what he said about Nogrod and Roa on Day1. Besides I have the impression that people have to correct his statements about their opinions all the time.

TGWBS's and Saucepan's relation to each other (what Nogrod spoke about yesterday) and also their comments about each other make him look quite faithfulish too.

Also, Saucepan's sudden fierce attack against Lalaith (who I think innocent) kind of creeps me out.

I don't like SPM's continuous "the wolves might be flying under the radar" -claim. While this might be true, it's a very good means of getting attention from vocal players, mainly himself.

I personally don't think Gil's a faithful (wouldn't he show more interest in the game if he had a special role?) and his confused remark about Glirdy being killed by the wolves speaks for his innocence, as he doesn't strike me as the wolf who plays a confused villager -type.

I'm not very suspicious of Hookbill either. While there are suspicious things in his behaviour, I'd rather say they are beacuse of his relative newbieness and his personal style, not because he's a faithful. He seems genuine.

Legate slipping under the radar? There you might have a point, but making this great fuss about slip-under-the-radarers because (from my point of view) one mediocrely suspicious villager is very faithful-ish. By the way I must admit I have not managed to form a proper picture of Legate, Kath, Mith or Kitanna this far, just a vague impression whether they're more innocent or suspicious, and it troubles me since at least one of them is most probably a wolf.

~*~

Durelin seemed quite genuine late yesterDay... I'm not sure if I suspect her that much anymore... also, the spat between her and SPM (who I believe to be a faithful) maybe speaks for her innocence... I don't know...

I still think Lalaith innocent. She has good points and feels genuine. Also the first day when she voted Holby because she thought she was the cobbler sending signs to the faithfuls... I don't think a faithful would have said that. When fabricating such accusation, a thought "what if she really is?" must cross the faithful's mind and thus I think a faithful wouldn't say that...

~*~

I think I'm going to check TGWBS's relations to other people myself, since I don't trust Sauce at all...

I'm also going to try to form a clear picture of the horde of unsures.

[Mithalwen]

I am here ... reading through..though starting from scratch sinceI was clearly so wrong about TGWBS

3 wolves, 2 gifted, 5 ordos...

I have to say I am suspicious of Lalaith's theory that the quiet are innocent. Can't say that I don't want to have a close look at the Legate for a start, and you can never discount Kath and Kitanna....and Gil is so hard to pin down. But as I pointed out days ago we do not have the luxury of lynching for peace of mind