WW XXXIII - Other Minds and Hands - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Shastanis Althreduin · 05-22-2007, 02:39 PM

Spm is almost definately the cobbler, but if we absolutely have to look anywhere else, I suggest looking at Ang.

Haven't heard very much from Di; maybe I'll take a closer look at her.

Kath, oddly enough, seems innocent-ish to me... of course, I haven't played with her before, so I could be being misled.

Gil is by far the most suspicious to me at least, based on yesterday's end-of-day retraction to Volo, and some of today's posts.

Aganzir is definately innocent.

Since today has been designated for house-cleaning, I can't be on any longer today, although I'll be able to get on tomorrow to change my vote if need be, but I thought I'd go ahead and vote....

++Gil

I'll be on before the deadline tomorrow, and I'll retract and vote for Spm if everyone decides to get rid of the cobbler.

*picks up a featherduster and gets to work.... sigh*

Aganzir · 05-22-2007, 03:04 PM

Sorry, but I just had to bring this up again. Just for my own fun, you know, I don't expect it helps us toDay.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Espiem after Boro's death

So, assuming that there were two Wolves among the Legate voters, then I consider one of Rune, Aganzir and Diamond to be a Wolf.

Legate voters were Shasta, Spm and Boro.
Spm meant to say Boro voters, but everyone has heard of Freudian slips.

I must say I don't like Shasta's vote. I think Gil's somewhat suspicious, but toDay it's of greatest importance to know who we are going to kill before being hasty.

It's a 1/3 chance of Gil being a Wolf or Ang being a Wolf or anyone else being a Wolf, but it's 50-50 chance that Spm is one.
Killing an ordo toDay leads to everybody's death, except the Wolves' and the Cobbler's.
Killing the Cobbler wins us more time. Killing a Wolf wins us more time.
I would rather see the Cobbler dead than witness the village losing because everybody thinks fitting to vote someone they suspect the most. It's time for cooperation.

If you indeed are an innocent, Shasta, I strongly recommend to retract and vote Spm! It's 2 Wolves + the Cobbler against four innocents, and if even one ordo votes another ordo, we're doomed.

It's annoying as well for me as for you to see me repeating the same things, but I can't help it. Our remaining Wolves are not stupid, and neither is our Cobbler. They will mislead you, given the chance.

Aganzir · 05-22-2007, 03:57 PM

Anguirel can be anything. If Sauce's not the Cobbler, I think it's possible that he is. He's done a lot of suspicious things, but then again he has got himself out of the situations pretty easily. I know I should watch out for him more, but it's difficult.

Diamond. Well, it was practically her vote that killed Boro, but Legate wouldn't have been any better lynchee. She voted Mac two times.
I'm slightly surprised how Spm could have persuaded her to doubt if it was Mac or Volo who was telling the truth.
Well, I guess she might be innocent, but don't count on that.

Gil suspected Mac already on Day3, and voted for him then. YesterDay he voted Mac at first, but switched to Volo a few minutes before the deadline. It's incredibly hard to believe that an innocent Gil would have done that. Well, I understand why you may have thought that double lynch was a good idea, but a few minutes before the deadline...

I think he's been really suspicious toDay (remembering the number of the Wolves wrong, insisting without evidence that Spm is the Cobbler...), too, but it might just be his way and me being paranoid. I want anyway see Spm dead before him.

There's something wrong with Kath's posts, especially the ones she posted when Volo and Mac were arguing about the Seer thing. They just struck me as not genuine. Towards the end of that Day she calmed down and started again speaking like an innocent, but the former posts left a little uncomfortable feeling.
Anyway I'm more inclined to consider her innocent, but here I can be terribly wrong.

Shasta is quite suspicious. He has had some good points, but then on the other hand I don't always understand his reasoning. Now that we know about Rune I find it somewhat interesting that Shasta suspected him on basis of his "safe" vote for Mac on Day2 I think.
He has voted for Legate, Rune and Volo, all innocents, and now for Gil. On Day2 he voted early and without any good explanation because he didn't want to be mod-killed.
I don't know what I should make out from all this.

Anyway, I'm going to sleep now, it's 1 AM.

++ THE SAUCEPAN MAN

I'll be back, before the deadline, but I don't intend to retract my vote.

05-22-2007, 02:39 PM	#1
Shastanis Althreduin Werewolf Psychic Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: In fire, water, earth, and air. But mostly water. Posts: 2,832	Spm is almost definately the cobbler, but if we absolutely have to look anywhere else, I suggest looking at Ang. Haven't heard very much from Di; maybe I'll take a closer look at her. Kath, oddly enough, seems innocent-ish to me... of course, I haven't played with her before, so I could be being misled. Gil is by far the most suspicious to me at least, based on yesterday's end-of-day retraction to Volo, and some of today's posts. Aganzir is definately innocent. Since today has been designated for house-cleaning, I can't be on any longer today, although I'll be able to get on tomorrow to change my vote if need be, but I thought I'd go ahead and vote.... ++Gil I'll be on before the deadline tomorrow, and I'll retract and vote for Spm if everyone decides to get rid of the cobbler. picks up a featherduster and gets to work.... sigh __________________ Shasta– ... However, if he's innocent his famous clairvoyant powers must be taking the week off. Meanwhile, the Night-kills have been awfully effective– almost like we're dealing with a psychic wolf... - Nerwen, WW LXXV

05-22-2007, 03:57 PM	#3
Aganzir Woman of Secret Shadow Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: in hollow halls beneath the fells Posts: 4,511	Anguirel can be anything. If Sauce's not the Cobbler, I think it's possible that he is. He's done a lot of suspicious things, but then again he has got himself out of the situations pretty easily. I know I should watch out for him more, but it's difficult. Diamond. Well, it was practically her vote that killed Boro, but Legate wouldn't have been any better lynchee. She voted Mac two times. I'm slightly surprised how Spm could have persuaded her to doubt if it was Mac or Volo who was telling the truth. Well, I guess she might be innocent, but don't count on that. Gil suspected Mac already on Day3, and voted for him then. YesterDay he voted Mac at first, but switched to Volo a few minutes before the deadline. It's incredibly hard to believe that an innocent Gil would have done that. Well, I understand why you may have thought that double lynch was a good idea, but a few minutes before the deadline... I think he's been really suspicious toDay (remembering the number of the Wolves wrong, insisting without evidence that Spm is the Cobbler...), too, but it might just be his way and me being paranoid. I want anyway see Spm dead before him. There's something wrong with Kath's posts, especially the ones she posted when Volo and Mac were arguing about the Seer thing. They just struck me as not genuine. Towards the end of that Day she calmed down and started again speaking like an innocent, but the former posts left a little uncomfortable feeling. Anyway I'm more inclined to consider her innocent, but here I can be terribly wrong. Shasta is quite suspicious. He has had some good points, but then on the other hand I don't always understand his reasoning. Now that we know about Rune I find it somewhat interesting that Shasta suspected him on basis of his "safe" vote for Mac on Day2 I think. He has voted for Legate, Rune and Volo, all innocents, and now for Gil. On Day2 he voted early and without any good explanation because he didn't want to be mod-killed. I don't know what I should make out from all this. Anyway, I'm going to sleep now, it's 1 AM. ++ THE SAUCEPAN MAN I'll be back, before the deadline, but I don't intend to retract my vote. __________________ He bit me, and I was not gentle.