WW XXXIII - Other Minds and Hands

[Diamond18]

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Di, I guess you, too, should have known better than to be confused if the liar was Mac or Volo.

Those were not accusations but questions.

"should have known better" sounds like an accusation to me, not so much of wolvishness as of poor gameplay. I had some momentary doubt when reading over SpM's persuasive arguments -- he's devilishly good at that. But in the end I didn't change my mind, so I don't see why you're complaining. I've been doing my best to figure things out in my limited reading/pondering time and didn't want to just disregard SpM's (rather loud) arguments without at least considering it for a while.

Anyway, now I'm quite certain that SpM is either a wolf or a cobbler. And Gil is looking very wolfish at the moment with his insistence that we ignore SpM to the point of not considering that he be a wolf. Right now, if I had to, I'd bet that SpM and Gil are wolves. Actually, are we 100% certain that there is a cobbler in this game? I should probably know this but I'd appreciate it pointed out where the clue was, etc. If there is a cobble I'm suspecting either Ang or SpM of that role. I very much dislike Ang's suggestion of double lynching.

[Gil-Galad]

well i want to vote Ang... but i don't want to split the vote too much so

++SPM

oh and aganzir,

Gil suspected Mac already on Day3, and voted for him then. YesterDay he voted Mac at first, but switched to Volo a few minutes before the deadline. It's incredibly hard to believe that an innocent Gil would have done that. Well, I understand why you may have thought that double lynch was a good idea, but a few minutes before the deadline... I think he's been really suspicious toDay (remembering the number of the Wolves wrong, insisting without evidence that Spm is the Cobbler...), too, but it might just be his way and me being paranoid.

you obviously have not played enough werewolf games with me... read the old games and this will solve your statements

and shasta, i get this weird feeling your not to fond of me in these games... also thank you for talking up today