Werewolf Four and Thirty: Bloodbath in the Anduin Vale - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Rikae · 06-03-2007, 08:08 AM

Well, I am completely baffled at this point. A few random thoughts:

If Durelin had some sort of seerish ("spying") ability, isn't it highly likely Kath is guilty? Oh, well. Maybe she used that strange vote for cover of some kind...but still, it's the closest to a trail we have for her. I will have to go over Kath's posts with a fine toothed comb...so to speak...

Hmmm. Kath's reasoning on Lommy bothers me. Indecisiveness? "It could be this or it could be that"? Hasn't there been a phrase coined already..."Lommy flip-flopping" -? It seems too easy, to call Lommy "one to watch" for this reason..

I also have to disagree vehemently on Boro and Menel's arguing. One of my first thoughts on learning of Menel's wolvishness was that that little exchange had wolf-on-wolf argument written all over it. I will have to go back and see if I can be more specific- but it felt rather planned.

Aganzir's analysis makes no sense whatsoever, since she leaves out Durelin's killers. Um...somebody killed Durelin...I absolutely don't understand making a whole analysis based on the premise there were two kills, when there were three....

Menel's posts might be our best lead today. Sixth's treatment was far too simplified and inconclusive.

One more thing...Legate does not feel right, and I'm keeping my eye on him...and Izzy is working from the fly-under-the-radar wolf textbook, doing the minimum, posting vote counts & in character banter...

I'll try to look into things more in depth later toDay.

Giving off bad vibes:

Kath
Izzy
Legate
Boro
Aganzir

Slightly uneasy about:

Nogrod
TGWBS - Who seems oddly quiet, and should speak up.
Gil-Galad - Who is completely silent!
Mith
Morm
Sixth

Haven't tripped any alarms for me (possibly suspicious for that reason!):

Fea
Lommy
Volo
Shasta

There are several people who are managing to escape notice, and that's disturbing. We ignore someone at our peril.

EDIT: X'd with Leggy.

06-03-2007, 08:08 AM	#11
Rikae Mellifluous Maia Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: A glade open to the stars, deep in Nan Elmoth Posts: 3,489	Well, I am completely baffled at this point. A few random thoughts: If Durelin had some sort of seerish ("spying") ability, isn't it highly likely Kath is guilty? Oh, well. Maybe she used that strange vote for cover of some kind...but still, it's the closest to a trail we have for her. I will have to go over Kath's posts with a fine toothed comb...so to speak... Hmmm. Kath's reasoning on Lommy bothers me. Indecisiveness? "It could be this or it could be that"? Hasn't there been a phrase coined already..."Lommy flip-flopping" -? It seems too easy, to call Lommy "one to watch" for this reason.. I also have to disagree vehemently on Boro and Menel's arguing. One of my first thoughts on learning of Menel's wolvishness was that that little exchange had wolf-on-wolf argument written all over it. I will have to go back and see if I can be more specific- but it felt rather planned. Aganzir's analysis makes no sense whatsoever, since she leaves out Durelin's killers. Um...somebody killed Durelin...I absolutely don't understand making a whole analysis based on the premise there were two kills, when there were three.... Menel's posts might be our best lead today. Sixth's treatment was far too simplified and inconclusive. One more thing...Legate does not feel right, and I'm keeping my eye on him...and Izzy is working from the fly-under-the-radar wolf textbook, doing the minimum, posting vote counts & in character banter... I'll try to look into things more in depth later toDay. Giving off bad vibes: Kath Izzy Legate Boro Aganzir Slightly uneasy about: Nogrod TGWBS - Who seems oddly quiet, and should speak up. Gil-Galad - Who is completely silent! Mith Morm Sixth Haven't tripped any alarms for me (possibly suspicious for that reason!): Fea Lommy Volo Shasta There are several people who are managing to escape notice, and that's disturbing. We ignore someone at our peril. EDIT: X'd with Leggy.