Werewolf Four and Thirty: Bloodbath in the Anduin Vale - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Boromir88 · 06-03-2007, 04:19 PM

Quote:

So Boro said he could go for Isabell as well as Aganzir?

Oh what the heck, since enough people are talking about Isabell (I think Legate also said he may vote for her) lets give this a shot:

++Isabellyka

Boromir88 · 06-03-2007, 04:21 PM

Quote:

This is only going to make you look worse tomorrow - whatever Kath's role is.~Rikae

You think I don't know that? You better not be doubting my ability to get out of a little bit of suspicion.

the guy who be short · 06-05-2007, 01:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Morm

Does it seem to anybody else that Thinlo and Volo are having a bit too much fun in all this and that they are the leaders in diverting our attention?

Good point, monkey man.

Now then... before I saw today's death, Rikae was actually my top suspect. It may, therefore, be possible that we have an assassin who merely screwed up. However, I myself think there are two wolf groups due to the little narrative clue Aganzir found.

The important thing is that it doesn't matter, as morm said, unless we kill them.

I'm going to go through Legate's post myself now, as there should always be independent verification. It does strike me, though, that people are being a little paranoid. Perhaps Legate was simply killed because he was both helpful and unsuspected.

the guy who be short · 06-05-2007, 01:58 AM

From Day 2 onwards, as he didn't get a dream before Day 1... did he?

This post makes me think he dreamt of Boro.

This however suggests Rikae more strongly, and I think that's what we should go for.

In addition, I just thought I'd mention about that I don't think the Isabell bandwagon yesterday was serious at all. Many, myself included, thought her slightly suspicious but not enough to vote for. Then, suddenly, she had amassed loads of votes in an effort to prevent Kath dying. I think this is probably due to some Western instinct that for democracy to work, there should be more than one candidate, than anything else. In short: it was a bit farcical.

the guy who be short · 06-05-2007, 02:03 AM

Whoever Menel's ally/allies is/are, they are loud. Thus Menel pushing us to lynch the quiet.

Whoever killed Rune was quiet, thus killing the guy who most clearly and strongly believed in killing the quiet as quickly as possible.

I think we should heed Rune's words, and his death was possibly designed lest we forget them: We should deal with quieter people earlier on, i.e. now. This ie because later on, we'll have formed strong opinions about the loud, so we''' know whether we want to lynch them or not. We'll still we confused about the quiet, however; later in the game, confusion can be deadly.

Therefore, I shall be voting for a quiet person today.

It helps that Boro feels innocent to be, and Noggy too, if slightly less so.

the guy who be short · 06-05-2007, 02:17 AM

According to my books, the quiet includes, from quietest to loudest:

morm - 4 posts.
Isabellkya - 5 posts.
Fea - 7 posts.
Shasta - 9 posts.
Sixth - 9 posts.

As Fea seems to have some sort of excuse, I'll move her to the bottom of my list and commence analysing, in the following order:

morm
Isabellkya
Shasta
Sixth
Fea

the guy who be short · 06-05-2007, 02:25 AM

Mormegil:
DAY 2
Post 133 - Says nothing useful.
Post 135 - "Trust me or not, Mith is innocent." Why...?
Post 154 - Votes Kath on the basis that "Kath is Kath and I'm happier if she's dead."
DAY 3
Post 276 - Points out that we have no idea what roles there are, so discussion is a bit pointless. Suspects Volo and Lommy.

Now, I'm used to a crazily loud morm. There may indeed be time constraints, but even then I'd expect him to be more active than he has been. That said, a changed playing style cannot be used to cast guilt on somebody.

What can be used is that he has said so very little that it is incredibly difficult to get a picture of him. I suspect most people forgot about him.

Today's post does seem to be promising in offering some worthwhile content. Hopefully this will continue. I'll humour that hope and leave morm alone for now. If he doesnt shape up, I will go after him tomorrow though. I'm not asking him to be as loud as I know he can be - only to say things of actual worth, which he has thus far largely avoided.

06-05-2007, 01:58 AM	#4
the guy who be short Shadowed Prince Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Thulcandra Posts: 2,343	Leggy From Day 2 onwards, as he didn't get a dream before Day 1... did he? This post makes me think he dreamt of Boro. This however suggests Rikae more strongly, and I think that's what we should go for. In addition, I just thought I'd mention about that I don't think the Isabell bandwagon yesterday was serious at all. Many, myself included, thought her slightly suspicious but not enough to vote for. Then, suddenly, she had amassed loads of votes in an effort to prevent Kath dying. I think this is probably due to some Western instinct that for democracy to work, there should be more than one candidate, than anything else. In short: it was a bit farcical.

06-05-2007, 02:03 AM	#5
the guy who be short Shadowed Prince Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Thulcandra Posts: 2,343	Further thoughts Whoever Menel's ally/allies is/are, they are loud. Thus Menel pushing us to lynch the quiet. Whoever killed Rune was quiet, thus killing the guy who most clearly and strongly believed in killing the quiet as quickly as possible. I think we should heed Rune's words, and his death was possibly designed lest we forget them: We should deal with quieter people earlier on, i.e. now. This ie because later on, we'll have formed strong opinions about the loud, so we''' know whether we want to lynch them or not. We'll still we confused about the quiet, however; later in the game, confusion can be deadly. Therefore, I shall be voting for a quiet person today. It helps that Boro feels innocent to be, and Noggy too, if slightly less so.

06-05-2007, 02:17 AM	#6
the guy who be short Shadowed Prince Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Thulcandra Posts: 2,343	The quiet According to my books, the quiet includes, from quietest to loudest: morm - 4 posts. Isabellkya - 5 posts. Fea - 7 posts. Shasta - 9 posts. Sixth - 9 posts. As Fea seems to have some sort of excuse, I'll move her to the bottom of my list and commence analysing, in the following order: morm Isabellkya Shasta Sixth Fea

06-05-2007, 02:25 AM	#7
the guy who be short Shadowed Prince Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Thulcandra Posts: 2,343	Mormegil: DAY 2 Post 133 - Says nothing useful. Post 135 - "Trust me or not, Mith is innocent." Why...? Post 154 - Votes Kath on the basis that "Kath is Kath and I'm happier if she's dead." DAY 3 Post 276 - Points out that we have no idea what roles there are, so discussion is a bit pointless. Suspects Volo and Lommy. Now, I'm used to a crazily loud morm. There may indeed be time constraints, but even then I'd expect him to be more active than he has been. That said, a changed playing style cannot be used to cast guilt on somebody. What can be used is that he has said so very little that it is incredibly difficult to get a picture of him. I suspect most people forgot about him. Today's post does seem to be promising in offering some worthwhile content. Hopefully this will continue. I'll humour that hope and leave morm alone for now. If he doesnt shape up, I will go after him tomorrow though. I'm not asking him to be as loud as I know he can be - only to say things of actual worth, which he has thus far largely avoided.