Werewolf Four and Thirty: Bloodbath in the Anduin Vale

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

But Volo, Gil may be in a pack - if the three sticks was a hint . Then he probably needn't be active at night either. I don't think we can be absolutely certain he isn't a problem. And we will look so stupid if he is.. but not knowing the number of wolves/beasts means that we don't know the odds. And so can't judge how much of a risk it is.

Yeah? I for one dropped the wondering of "how many Wolves and in how many packs they are" -thoughts. No, I don't understand it, but I did put a stop to some theory-making time gone wasted.

If Gil is Wolf: He makes the Wolves' victory easier by one person. He can't kill, he can't vote, nothing else.

If Gil is Innocent/Goodie: He makes the Wolves' victory harder by one person.

It is more probable that he's a Goodie. But if he is a Wolf, then he'll be passified if we lynch the other Wolves first.