Osse -Psycho of the Seven Seas

[Ghazi]

Originally Posted by Elmo

While I can understand the realpolitik of Manwe's decision to let him into the fold, does no-one think the fact that storm-lovin' Osse is one of the 'good' guys undermines the goodness of the Elder King and the rest of the Valar.

No, not at all. I seem to remember from the Sil that Osse could be a nice guy. He was enamoured with the Teleri, and especially Cirdan's folk, wasn't he? Wasn't he also sad to see them leave for Valinor and didn't he beg them to stay in Beleriand? I guess none of that necessarily made him nice but at least one can tell he was soft on some of the elves.