WW XXXX - The scouring of the Shire, vol.2

[Volo]

Thanks Lommy, (although it's hard to believe that you gathered all of that so soon.)

I don't think Kath Dreamed of Lily, there was no need for it at that time and I think her vote looks more like pure logic than a Seer's Dream.

And I can't think that she Dreamed of you, Lommy, either (although I'll feel happy if it was so, as I tossed a guess that you had been Dreamed of on Day1 or 2.). She would have mentioned you differently.

Her Night1 Dream is a mystery, Might jumps into my mind, but could she have been so obvious? Probably no. And although I'd Dream of a new player myself, I have doubts in whether Kath would do so - actually to flip-flop with my preveous though, she would probably have Dreamed of Lily rather than of Might.

Her obvious Night2 Dream would be Brinniel, but it feels too obvious.

I'm quite sure her Night3 Dream was morm.


Might and Brinn seem obvious, but could it be that the Wolves didn't kill her on Night2 and 3 because of fear for the Ranger - she was, after all, killed as soon as the Ranger was down.

Aargh, my head is going to explode, I should go to sleep...


EDIT: Xd with everything since my preveous post.

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Lommy

What??

The first is what I felt straight after morm's and sally's deaths.
The second from just before toDay started. It still doesn't mean that I'll go far enough to trust anybody, except maybe Legate, but he's dead. :/

Originally Posted by Lommy

I don't understand why Volo rambles about rangers. It's a bit weird, and not in a positive way.

Because I'm annoyed? (Nothing personal at all morm, I just don't understand why you decided to keep it a secret through that situation...)

Originally Posted by Lommy

On the other hand, his first angst seems quite unfeigned and kind of familiar...

:O Oh... I mean, have I done that before?

Originally Posted by Lommy

I find it funny how differently we read her posts. I think other people should look at her posts as well and say what they think. Comparing the results would be interesting.

I agree! It wouldn't only be interesting, but also useful - probably.

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Volo

Thanks Lommy, (although it's hard to believe that you gathered all of that so soon.)

Well, you have to remember Kath only made 10 posts in total...

Originally Posted by Volo

I don't think Kath Dreamed of Lily, there was no need for it at that time and I think her vote looks more like pure logic than a Seer's Dream.

A valid point, though I'm not sure I agree.

Originally Posted by Volo

Her Night1 Dream is a mystery, Might jumps into my mind, but could she have been so obvious? Probably no.

I agree. And I think she would have mentioned him again on Day3 if she had dreamt of him.

Originally Posted by Volo

Her obvious Night2 Dream would be Brinniel, but it feels too obvious.

I think the way she speculates about Brinn and morm seems like she hadn't dreamt of her... Remember she said she doubts morm is wolf unless Brinn is one too...

I think TM looks quite innocent. I mean, he's long past the point of wolvishness: he's too suspicious. No wolf in his right mind would play like that. Besides, he reminds me of my first game ever, when I was an ordo and about as silly as he's now, no offense.

And Aganzir could be lynched just for being so nasty.

Yesterday, when I posted my misguided theory, I realised it could be used for testing people's reactions as well. If you recall, I even asked what you thought of it. I think Menel's way of responding with a comment that it's very interesting and possibly credible (or something along those lines) looks quite fishy. I mean, it looks like a wolf smelling an opportunity.

edit: xed with Volo

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

I think the way she speculates about Brinn and morm seems like she hadn't dreamt of her... Remember she said she doubts morm is wolf unless Brinn is one too...

I think this means that she did dream about Brinn, and now this makes more sense to me. On Night1 she Dreamed of morm, as morm is a dangerous player. On Night2 she Dreamed of Brinn and found that she's Innocent.
The way she says "unless Brinniel turns out to be a wolf I doubt morm is one" I understand it that both players are of the same side. But then why would she put Brinn into the suspicious list, it feels like a contradiction to me and makes it impossible to find out whom she Dreamed of.

I think TM looks quite innocent. I mean, he's long past the point of wolvishness: he's too suspicious. No wolf in his right mind would play like that. Besides, he reminds me of my first game ever, when I was an ordo and about as silly as he's now, no offense.

If he's a Wolf, he's doing splendidly. But his last posts are indeed giving a genuine feel and I wouldn't accuse him too much because of the double-lynch. I admit that I'd have done that and Lommy seems to admit it too, don't you?
I do suspect him, but the double-lynch, as nasty as it was, doesn't tell us much about him. I'm talking nonsense - sometimes Might feels just so so Wolf-like, but so did Sally and there's a lot of similarities in their behavior. :/

I suspect Menel much more. And this -

Originally Posted by Kath

I can't explain it, he's just not fitting right to me.

- looks like she Dreamed about Menel, on Night3 - probably. So forget what I said in my preveous post about morm being Dreamed of on Night3.


I really really hope that these people will speak up:
Shastanis Althreduin
Macalaure
Feanor of the Peredhil
Kuruharan


EDIT Xd with Aganzir

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Because this looks such a fabricated reason to claim them both innocent.

Ha! Well found! I agree, although the part about Brinn still doesn't make sense to me.

Ok, I'll try to leave now - sorry for being confusing and changing my opinion often.

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Volo

If he's a Wolf, he's doing splendidly. But his last posts are indeed giving a genuine feel and I wouldn't accuse him too much because of the double-lynch. I admit that I'd have done that and Lommy seems to admit it too, don't you?

No. I considered the possibility, but decided against it, as you might see frmo my late yesterDay posts. But, ironically, when I saw the results I was quite happy, ashamed and horrified that TM had the guts to do what I didn't dare to. The reason why I didn't dare to do it was because I did think it was possible (yet unprobable) I was wrong about them and I must admit I also ended up not trying to double-lynch Sally and morm because I saw it as a lost chance.