Werewolf XLVIII: When Virtual Becomes Reality - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Formendacil · 07-13-2008, 04:42 PM

Of all the Days to get a headache and come on late... I mean, we still have twenty-plus minutes, but this double-revelation business has me very confused...

On the one hand, I still very much want to see Shasta as dead, since his vote continues to strike me tenderly... but I have to say that his "proof" of innocence... which I'm not entirely sure wasn't planted... has at least the semblance of validity.

Boromir, on the other hand, is entirely capable of pulling a double-bluff like this, as I recall from games long past--though that was cobbler he was bluffing at in the last hours. Still, the knowledge of his capability leads me to think him suspicious, especially in light of Shasta's self-revelation.

On the other-other hand... Boromir was hardly appearing lynchworthy today. Why come forward--if he's a wolf? Even if we didn't kill Shasta Ranger today, he'd still have revealed, and they could eat him at night... and in all probability another innocent would be lynched.

Eomer, I really wish you hadn't taken off right before this... the guidance of our only apparently-Innocent would have been appreciated, though I guess I can always follow your vote (and I'm still bitter enough over yesterDay to like the example set).

07-13-2008, 04:42 PM	#11
Formendacil Dead Serious Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Perched on Thangorodrim's towers. Posts: 3,328	Of all the Days to get a headache and come on late... I mean, we still have twenty-plus minutes, but this double-revelation business has me very confused... On the one hand, I still very much want to see Shasta as dead, since his vote continues to strike me tenderly... but I have to say that his "proof" of innocence... which I'm not entirely sure wasn't planted... has at least the semblance of validity. Boromir, on the other hand, is entirely capable of pulling a double-bluff like this, as I recall from games long past--though that was cobbler he was bluffing at in the last hours. Still, the knowledge of his capability leads me to think him suspicious, especially in light of Shasta's self-revelation. On the other-other hand... Boromir was hardly appearing lynchworthy today. Why come forward--if he's a wolf? Even if we didn't kill Shasta Ranger today, he'd still have revealed, and they could eat him at night... and in all probability another innocent would be lynched. Eomer, I really wish you hadn't taken off right before this... the guidance of our only apparently-Innocent would have been appreciated, though I guess I can always follow your vote (and I'm still bitter enough over yesterDay to like the example set). __________________ I prefer history, true or feigned.