Tol-in-Gaurhoth XLIX - At the Source of Darkness

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Dur

Another interesting thing is that he could have voted for Lommy, if he was aware of Mith's vote for Lommy and made her the lynchee instead of Gwath if he wanted.

First- I wasn't aware of Mith's vote when I went to make my post.
Second- I still would've voted Gwath, as even with Mith's vote he still had the lead. I was voting for the leader, plain and simple. I had no interest in leaving the door open for me to retake the lead and get lynched.

Originally Posted by Dur

I have to agree with Nogrod and tp on the most likely seer dreams, because listing people as 'innocent' was the only certain thing he did. Everyone is aware that the seer actually can't tell if the person is a cobbler, he doesn't need to specify that.

Thank you!!

It's nice to know that at least a couple of people can see what is smack in front of their faces.

Now, onto Eonwe, who seriously thinks that a Phantom-Wolf would kill a Mith-Cobbler. If you had been reading my posts today, you would've read that post where I point out that from my perspective Mith came across as rather Cobblerish yesterday.

So me being an intelligent WW decided I'd kill someone who was not only a Cobbler, but a Cobbler who had a special soft spot for me and would be extremely likely to continue helping me. Oh yes, makes perfect sense.

Originally Posted by Eonwe

Maybe he thought (whatever he says he did) that Mith was the seer and had found them both out.

Oh, now that makes even more sense! I killed Mith because I thought she was the Seer. Oh, of course!

No... wait.... the Seer was already dead, wasn't he?

Seriously Eonwe- try and think your arguments through before you post them. You can't just pick someone to go after despite all the facts.

(to be continued)